giants_fan 0 Posted September 12, 2007 I was offered a trade that looks like this.... I would get both Adrian Petersons and a "player of my choice" for Chad Johnson. Should I do this trade? if so, who should be the "player of my choice"? Please give me 2-3 ideas of who this player could be. MY TEAM.... P. Rivers - QB Bensen - RB Gore - RB Chad Johnson - WR Colsten - WR Cooley - TE Vinatieri - K Patriots - Def ----- Reserves Delhomme - QB Chester Taylor - RB Michael Turner - RB T.J. Duckett - RB Ronald Curry - WR Drew Bennett - WR OTHER TEAM Cutler, Jay QB Parker, Willie RB Peterson, Adrian RB Johnson, Calvin WR Smith, Steve WR Clark, Dallas TE Brown, Josh K Bears, DST DST RESERVES Campbell, Jason QB Jackson, Brandon RB Peterson, Adrian RB Portis, Clinton RB White, LenDale RB Bruce, Isaac WR Thanks for your time and help! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BiscuitBoy 0 Posted September 12, 2007 I would take Steve Smith as the other player. He is still a #1 receiver and Jake Delhomme looks like he is going to have a good year again after the STL game. Carolina looked impressive as a whole, you would get a #1 RB & #1 WR out of the deal. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
bpork 0 Posted September 12, 2007 I was offered a trade that looks like this....I would get both Adrian Petersons and a "player of my choice" for Chad Johnson. Should I do this trade? if so, who should be the "player of my choice"? Please give me 2-3 ideas of who this player could be. MY TEAM.... P. Rivers - QB Bensen - RB Gore - RB Chad Johnson - WR Colsten - WR Cooley - TE Vinatieri - K Patriots - Def ----- Reserves Delhomme - QB Chester Taylor - RB Michael Turner - RB T.J. Duckett - RB Ronald Curry - WR Drew Bennett - WR OTHER TEAM Cutler, Jay QB Parker, Willie RB Peterson, Adrian RB Johnson, Calvin WR Smith, Steve WR Clark, Dallas TE Brown, Josh K Bears, DST DST RESERVES Campbell, Jason QB Jackson, Brandon RB Peterson, Adrian RB Portis, Clinton RB White, LenDale RB Bruce, Isaac WR Thanks for your time and help! player of your choice?? Too good to be true... The main problem with your trade is that colston is not looking so good and you're going to trade your other WR...curry is not proven. Unless the player of your choice is one of his top WR, i would not do this Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Djurynk 0 Posted September 12, 2007 I wouldn't make the trade but Steve Smith would be the guy as your losing a Number 1 stud and need to replace it with a number #1. Smith is really good and does come with the injury tag, but if you need Adrian P badly SMith is the man to make the trade for.. THANKS for mine.. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
E-Knuckle Shuffle 0 Posted September 12, 2007 I have to agree with steve smith. any other trade will down grade your team, unless you take FWP and try to trade one of your other running backs to another owner for Marvin/TO. Now I'm just digressing. Only do it if you can get steve smith. http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=286341 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites