Mid-draft Trade offer - Addai for Eli?

[manola 0]

I've been offered:

 

Eli Manning,

Rookie Draft Pick #1.9 (Probably Draft Jerious Norwood or Greg Jennings)

 

For

 

Joseph Addai (Just picked him at #1.4),

Rookie Pick #2.2 (Maybe Chad Jackson or Sinorice Moss?)

 

On My Roster Right Now:

Kurt Warner,

Phillip Rivers

 

Portis,

Westbrook,

Moats,

Reggie Bush,

Lawrence Maroney,

Greg Jones,

Michael Turner

 

Would you make this deal?

 

Thanks.

 

I'll answer yours!

[mathja 0]

I would definitely do that....You're pretty strong at RB...and Eli could really blossom this year and end up starting for you over warner....

[STEELERMAN 0]

I would do it. Manning will eventually be your #1QB and Norwood could end up being better than Addai..He is now right behind Dunn & looks good so far!

[quentinfox 0]

You're rich at RB now and future. You need the help at QB.

 

Please see mine.

[Ray_T 587]

you'd be dumb not to do that trade.

 

Eli manning is guaranteed to put up respectable numbers for you. And he has the potential to put up spectacular numbers.

 

Addai has proven nothing. He has good potential, but at this point, that's all he has. He may put up good numbers in the future, but I dont think he will become an elite player.

 

Manning has that potential, so I think you have to do it.

[ndancosse 0]

i agree also ..getting ELI is the key with your depth at rb ...if eli blossoms like he should you have your qb for years to come ..if he doesnt you still have Rivers who could blossom as well ...so you will have very good depth at rb and qb ...nice team to have

[Vilma=GOD 0]

I would do it, Eli will be a great fanasy QB while with your young RBs you're set for the future.

[ericg 0]

I would pull the trigger for sure. Addai has some potential but Elie has NO competition as the QB for NYG. Like others have said, he will prob be your number one by years end.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=223650