Mark Ingram, Eddie Lacy, or Doug Martin?

[bjj 0]

So, doing my mocks, I seem to find myself having to make this choice consistently in the bottom of the second/top of the third round. If you could only have 1, who would it be?

 

Will Martin do well even after signing his big contract?

 

Will Eddie Lacy play lights out in trying to get a new contract?

 

Will Ingram finally play 16 games and push his way into RB1 status?

 

 

[Crystal Meth Tweekers 26]

I don't like Martin. He doesn't play on 3rd down and gets all his points in a few games. He was boom or bust rookie year. Last year he had some good games but I swear it was for $$$

 

Lacy is playing for $$ and lost weight.

 

Ingram could be solid I am not sure I have never owned him. I know he caught passes and ran well last year.

 

Lacy, Ingram, Martin

[polecatt 401]

You could make a good case for each of them but I would take Lacy.

When it comes down to it I just believe he is the most talented of the 3.

All have injury/conditioning issues, all are the top RB on good offenses, TB will be improved, so it just comes down to who is the best over all player.

I believe that is Lacy.

[Mr Neil 63]

In my keeper league where a lot of first and second round talent off the board at the 8 spot im hoping for dez to fall to me. If not and there's no Zeke I'm looking at Keenan Allen or Eddie Lacy as my first round choice sadly. I think Slim Eddie may get the job done this year but the real issue is when they get down it'll be the James Starks show. That's what turns me off about Lacy more than anything

[weepaws 2,456]

I would pick Lacy.

[Poker Joker 7]

I am going to say Ingram, particularly if this is a PPR league.

 

After last year, the other two have to do some convincing for me.