Trade Help Needed

[jordan5535 0]

I Give:

 

Marvin Harrison

DeShaun Foster

Nate Berleson

 

I Get:

Tiki Barber

TJ Houshmandzadeh

Reggie Brown

 

Will answer yours........

[The Riddler 0]

I can't see the Colts running too much this year. I think they're going to party like it's 2004 and Harrison will have a gigantic year. Tiki has no where to go but down, and Foster has nowhere to go but up. Housh is good, but he's a #2, not a #1.

 

Don't make this trade.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=224062

[manola 0]

Without seeing the rest of your roster, I think you should make this trade.

 

Tiki should be a big upgrade at RB.

 

People seem to think Harrison will start to slow down soon, so it's not hard to imagine Housh performing close to as well as Harrision.

 

Reggie Brown also has a good chance to put up big numbers, so he's a plus over Burleson.

 

Overall, you gain at RB and I think you pretty much break even with the WRs.

 

Good luck!

 

Please see mine:

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=224081

[notJames 0]

It really depends on what other players you have, specifically the RBs. If you have at least upper-tier RB, listen to the Riddler and ixnay on the trade. He said what we're all thinking. And by "we" I mean "me".

 

 

Good luck Now, maybe you can help me out...

[bigmark3333 11]

i say go for it, tiki is a top 5 rb most likely and you arent giving up a ton to get that production. plus, tj is a good wr also on that offense

 

plz see mine

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=224088

[jordan5535 0]

Here is my Roster:

 

QB D. McNabb

WR M. Harrison

WR D. Mason

WR T. Glenn

RB R. Johnson

RB D. Foster

TE J. Shockey

W/T C. Cooley

W/R D. Rhodes

BN N. Burleson

BN K. Warner

BN M. Brunell

BN C. Perry

BN R. Ferguson

BN H. Baskett

BN J. Norwood

[The Riddler 0]

People seem to think Harrison will start to slow down soon, so it's not hard to imagine Housh performing close to as well as Harrision.

 

Which people think that? Harrison is going to be huge this year. TJ is a great #2, but he's not Harrison. I think Harrison has a chance to be the #1 WR in the league this year.

 

Make this trade...if you want to lose!

[templeheels 0]

Make the trade. Fantasy Football 101: It's always much harder to get quality RB than quality WR. Foster is good but has never finished a full season. Tiki is far superior.

[Bash 0]

First, thanks for replying in my thread earlier today.

 

On to your question, a question I really had to think about. I could make a good case either way. It's basically a trade of a great receiver-good back for a great back-good receiver.

 

My thoughts on the big players:

 

Harrison: Will have a good year--a polished route runner rather than a speedster--will be effective this year and beyond on a team with the best QB and a big question mark at RB--they will take to the air more this year.

 

Foster: Apparently the Panthers want to run more this year. Foster has the injury-prone tag on him, but at least the big injury came two years ago. A noteworth stat--he has had exactly 4 TDs in the past 3 years--that's total TDs.

 

Barber: Another big year for him, his production will be down a little, but he's still a stud.

 

Housh: Good #2 numbers for last year--I think he will see a slight decrease in his 2006 numbers with a tougher schedule.

 

In the end, I think Tiki and Housh will earn more points than Harrison and Foster. My qualms about the trade will be that your receivers will be on the weak side. Whatever you decide, good luck.

[GFYAssClown 0]

make the trade, you getting two top 10 backs, TO is screwing up again and glenn will put up good numbers for you!

 

 

see mine please. http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=224272

[lguero1 4]

pull the trigger. i think ur getting 2 upgrades. brown over nate. tiki over foster.