thannay

Just traded him straight up for Brandon Marshall. Already had Lynch, L. Bell & Ellington and needed a WR upgrade. Really like him rest of season but figured it was a good time to sell him given his recent performances.

FML, who would you start? Hillman or Moreno?

Sunny and 70 here

Literally in the exact same situation. It sucks.

HOU - Kubiak

When you have Foster & McCoy and are sick of Moss' baggage then yes I'm fine with it.

Packaged him and Randy Moss for Vincent Jackson and Pierre Garcon.

Benched him at the last second for Garcon, so didn't end up too bad. Was pretty pissed throughout the day until SNF.

How is Arizona, a first place team with a 3-2 record an option and the San Francisco 49ers, a last place team with an 0-5 record not an option?

Same - watched Hall in high school and I'm surprised he's come this far. I like Skelton a lot more long term, but he's too raw at this point. Still pissed that Cards management didn't make the McNabb deal - then we wouldn't have to be in this situation.

I'm basing this off what I watched in training camp and preseason. Of course that is much different than the regular season, so like you said we'll see.

Disagree slightly. His arm is fairly weak like Leinart's, but he still takes chances downfield. Leinart stopped throwing the deep ball after his sophomore season and started checking down every play.

AZ homer here, It can't get much worse than DA, trust me. Hall has definitely shown to be more accurate and mobile which will benefit our passing game. The problem is that I see the Cards transitioning to a more power football scheme as originally intended because Wells is healthy and our o-line continues be to horrific in pass protection. I'd expect the end result to be net-neutral.

He's still an upgrade over DA. The Cards biggest problem right now is their o-line - Hall had absolutely no time to throw yesterday.

You won't get the proper value for him because it's Peyton Hillis. The best value would be to just ride him out.