This. Not everything is the "most _____ ever." In fact, most things aren't.
Eli is a good qb who had a curve ranging from pretty sh!tty at times to amazing at times. His legacy is pretty much built on the fact that the high points of his play happened when it was the most important, on the biggest stage.
Honestly, id say he's borderline HOF. Good stats, but mostly just because he played a long time and was never really hurt. Has the two rings. But was never even in the conversation for the top three in the league in any given year.
To me, that is critical.
Sure it'd be nice if he was great every week or every season.
But twice the Giants were knocking on the door and he got them a championship. Against one of the greatest sports dynasties ever, no less.
No question dude belongs in the hall.