Blockbuster trade involving Shaun Alexander and LT

[tdubya 0]

Here are the lineups:

MINE

QB J. Delhomme

WR T. Holt

WR L. Fitzgerald

RB S. Alexander

TE J. Witten

W/R M. Muhammad

BN D. Culpepper

BN C. Dillon

BN W. Dunn

BN J. Lewis

BN J. Horn

 

HIS LINEUP

QB B. Roethlisberger

WR C. Johnson

WR Rod Smith

RB L. Tomlinson

TE L. Smith

W/R W. Parker

BN M. Anderson

BN T. Jones

BN A. Randle El

BN R. Dayne

BN L. White

BN D. Stallworth

 

I would give up Alexander and Dillon to get LT, Rod Smith & Mike Anderson.

 

I am a little weary of the Madden curse, Super Bowl loss hangover, and the loss of Hutchinson with Alexander. I am a Chargers homer and wanted to take LT with the 2nd pick, and this guy took LT with the #1 overall pick. Is this a wise trade, or should I hold on to Alexander?

 

Also, 10 team head-2-head league where we start QB, RB, WR, WR, RB/WR, TE, K

 

Thanks for your help!

[k9tofive 0]

If he wanted Alexander, why didn't he DRAFT HIM with #1 pick?

 

It's a terrible trade for you.

 

Based on your lineup you should have a POWERHOUSE every week. I don't care if I was the center in Seattle - SA is going to be a Top 5 RB at season's end.

 

Rod Smith and M Anderson would NOT make your starting roster while Dillon would certainly make his.

 

With Dunn, Dillon, Jamal (even with injury) you are bound to have one of them make it in the Flex slot.

[dalie 2]

Don't trade you give up way to much for what you get and he has all to gain.

[PanicAttack 13]

NO way!

I do not see the upside for you. Go with what you have the value in the trade is just not worth it. i know what your love is with LT but SA is just as good.

 

good luck

Mine?

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=222656

[Demon 0]

hell no! You are giving up Dillon for Rod Smith and Anderson? Are you kidding?

 

see mine

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=222797