trade first pick for Ronnie or Caddy and a third rounder?

[unckeyherb 2]

my team is in my sig line. I'll probably keep McGahee and Julius. last season I made a trade for an extra first round pick (i've got 6th and 8th overal). I made an offer to the guy with Ronnie. I offered my extra 1st rounder, #8 over all, for Ronnie and his third round pick. Is this a good trade? should I try for more/less?

 

Would you do it for Caddy instead? The guy with Caddy said he'd be interested in trading him

[harken34 0]

I would do it

[Wildman 0]

I'd do that for either of those backs. I'm higher on those Auburn backs than the two you plan to keep.

[unckeyherb 2]

I'd do that for either of those backs. I'm higher on those Auburn backs than the two you plan to keep.

 

 

which one makes more sense? I think that I can actually get Caddy and a second round. I'm a little higher on Ronnie, but Caddy and the advent of a second pick seems pretty nice.

[kristv 0]

which one makes more sense? I think that I can actually get Caddy and a second round. I'm a little higher on Ronnie, but Caddy and the advent of a second pick seems pretty nice.

 

 

I like what I'm hearing about Ronnie this offseason. I'd lean towards him as your choice, as he'll have nobody stealing carries from him. Can't say the same for Caddy though. I also don't like how Caddy broke down last season so early. I know they're talking about being more careful with him this season, but he just doesn't strike me as an every-down RB. With Rasta Ricky out of the picture in Miami, I think Ronnie will go off this season!

[Striker99 0]

ROnnnie!

[Bully Bears 0]

I really like Ronnie Brown this season...so I would do the deal for him if I could. thanks for answering mine.

 

No Williams to vulture carries/yds and tds either. Better offense around him with CPepp in the backfield with him.

[evenflow814 0]

I'd go with Brown. Caddy did break down a bit last season, and you may see Alstott take away goal line carries. Miami seems to be heading in the right direction with their offense, and I like Ronnie this year.