Jump to content

JibbaJabbah

Members
  • Content Count

    175
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

0 Neutral

About JibbaJabbah

  • Rank
    FF Geek
  1. JibbaJabbah

    Help with a dispute

    Thats the problem. The team that was 1-1 got the nod. Though one can argue that this is fair/unfair way to break up h2h, I felt if you went h2h you HAD to go with the team that had the best winning % of the group. I had the team with the highest total points, but I was 0-2 against one of the teams, if we stay in h2h format, I know I am out. That is why I questioned how the 1-1 team can even be the choice here regardless.
  2. JibbaJabbah

    Help with a dispute

    As an update, the commish decided to let the league vote which team should be in. Seems appropriate based upon these events and I am sure no self interests will apply here.....LOL Thanks for all the feedback.
  3. JibbaJabbah

    Help with a dispute

    Though I was the total points leader of the 3, above what my gut feeling when I seen this too. Though that team is last in points, if the h2h tie breaker is in place, i guess go with that. I just don't like that we have listed like 4 ways to do this already. Just seems like another tiebreaker would have been easier.
  4. JibbaJabbah

    Help with a dispute

    The team the commish selected was in the middle of the pack of the 3 teams in terms of total scoring. The team that went 2-1 for our h2h threesome, actually was in last in the league in total points. I still just have one question, at what point do you say h2h tiebreaker does not work and move on? And if you do the h2h thing, is there really a correct answer to "officially" break that down or is it just a matter of opinion?
  5. JibbaJabbah

    Help with a dispute

    Legit solution. I agree. The question is, at this point, is all of this really just opinion on how to break down the h2h tiebreaker between these three teams? Who is right? I can't even find a correct answer for this. Thats why I figured another tiebreaker was needed.
  6. JibbaJabbah

    Help with a dispute

    Here was the reason for the decision that was given: It was said that since two teams are in the same division, and one team beat the other 2 times, the team that lost there was behind in the division standings, therefore, should not be considered in the next "match up". Then he takes the 2-1 team, puts them side by side with the 1-1 team, and chooses the 1-1 team © because they beat the 2-1 team. So the team that will get the nod only split 1-1 with these other two teams. What I don't like, is that the team that makes the playoffs based on this decision (by our current rules), is technically behind the team that misses out of the playoffs since they lost to that team. I even asked the league now that we know 3 team ties like this can happen, and with our rules, when do we really move on to the next tiebreaker.....I thought this was evident, but maybe it was just me. In regards to the note on our commish, yes, our commish does play the team that is "selected" in this mess. He has been the commish of this league for years and has never been an issue, and actually, is a close personal friend. I asked for a link to where they came up with the above breakdown, like was it NFL, NCAA's, FF, and they really have not given me a link or a resource. The NFL is the closest system I have seen to this, but with the NFL, division standings are "true" since they all played each other the same amount, not some here and there. It just seems like h2h is being examined by opinions, and when it gets to that point, makes sense to move on. Another owner in the same league said "One team would have to sweep the other two teams for the tiebreaker to work, or then it has to go to another tiebreaker." The commish has not said why this idea is either correct or wrong.
  7. JibbaJabbah

    Help with a dispute

    I seen this rule, but in the NFL, all teams play each other an = amount of times. In our league, teams do not play each other the same amount of times. Some teams play teams in their division 2 times where others play only 1 time. Makes me think division standing is tricky to call like the NFL does. I respect this opinion above and thank you for the info.
  8. JibbaJabbah

    Help with a dispute

    Only 1 slot for 1 team available. So you are saying hte team with 2 wins and the best winning % combined should make it?
  9. JibbaJabbah

    Help with a dispute

    I am also ok with this decision listed above. As a note, the final decisino was: The team with the 1-1 record gets to make the playoffs. The team that was 2-1 did not get the nod because that team lost to the 1-1 team. Whats crazy is the team that was 1-2 beat the team getting the nod for the playoffs. I felt either we moved to another tiebreaker and/or the team with the most wins of the group (even though its not fully fair) was better than the team that only beat 1 of the two teams involved. Maybe I am crazy though.
  10. JibbaJabbah

    Help with a dispute

    Please keep these replies coming. My commish does read this and I want him to see what other people think about this who have no interests. Please any more feedback on all sides of this will help.
  11. JibbaJabbah

    Help with a dispute

    Here is a situation that has happened to a league that I am in. I will not put my opinion on what I think on this so that we all can be fair on what is best in this situation. There is a 3 way tie for the wild card in our league. All teams have the exact same record. Here is our tiebreakers: Winning % h2h Total points. Here are the 3 teams and what they did against each other in this league. Please note, these three teams all did not play the same amount of games against each other due to 2 teams being in the same division. So, how do you decide a 3 way tie using H2H scoring? Here are the teams record against each other. Team A beat team B, but lost 2 times to Team C Team B beat team C, but lost to team A So one team A 1-2 (combined against these teams), Team C was 1-1 and Team B was 2-1. In regards to total points, Team A has the most, Team B has the 2nd most, Team C was in 3ed. It seems that no matter what team we let go through based on h2h, one team will have to be out though they beat that team, which was the first tiebreaker. Being that our rules were not as clear as they should be for a 3 team tie, how would you handle this? Does this move to the next tiebreaker, or do you break out h2h and make a decision? If you break this down in h2h, where can I find a resource to find the best way to do that? I read what the NFL does, but in our league, our division teams don't play each team the same amount of times. Some play each other 2 times, others one time. A final decision was made already, and I will post that later, but I wanted to gather thoughts first for research purposes.
  12. Just looking for a league that will draft online and is competitive. Feel free to shoot me an email @ jpop77@gmail.com if there are some open spots. Thank you.
  13. JibbaJabbah

    Who has more value the rest of the year

    I take what I said back. I would take Kitna. I have now learned there will be more criticism around Jesus, not the human.
  14. JibbaJabbah

    Who has more value the rest of the year

    I would take Jesus. I feel that human QB's get way more criticism than Jesus ones.
  15. JibbaJabbah

    Drew Brees Owners

    Drew Brees is sporting a farmers tan today in Tampa. Expect a down week.
×