6 replies to this topic

[Gepetto]

I can keep 3 and these are my best options.  It's an auction league and the cost of each of these is great value so just based on the player and their position, who do you think is the best 3 of these 4 to keep.  8 team 2QB, 2RB, 3WR, 2FLEX, 2TE, PPR league.

 

Dalvin Cook

Adam Thielen

Evan Engram

Jimmy Garoppolo

[scottsind]

Cook

Thielen

Jimmy G

 

At first I put Evan Engram in there, but then read your whole post and saw it was a 2QB league.  Jimmy G will be a very serviceable QB2 with upside for your league.   

[Gepetto]

It's a 2 TE league too.  I might try hard to get Gronk and Kelce in the auction next year though as they were both kept last year so will be available to draft as we can only keep players for 1 year.

 

Engram vs. Garoppolo is where I'm having the hardest time deciding who to keep.  I also have Dak and Keenum to choose from.

 

Thanks for the help.

 

 

Anyone else have an opinion?

 

Thanks

[scottsind]

I think it depends on what is valued more in the league. I have never done an auction draft but it seems like the logical way of deciding this is if you want both for next year who is going to cost more during an auction to redraft and who will be coveted more? Maybe after saying that I tend to lean more towards keeping Engram as there are more viable QB options to choose from than TEs. You also have to consider who will be throwing to Engram so I am sure you will be paying attention in the offseason.

[Larry David]

Engram is the odd man out.  Don't make the mistake of dropping Garopollo.  He could very well be the next Aaron Rodgers.

 

Speaking of Engram...   http://www.fftodayfo...howtopic=473910

[polecatt]

I would drop Jimmy G

I know he's the hot topic right now but QBs will be easy to come by

[Bills04]

I think you HAVE TO keep Jimmy G. and Cook.

 

*If* you think Engram wasn't a one-year wonder (due to all the injuries to the WRs - see Jeremy Shockey's rookie year!!), then don't keep Thielen.