2008 Geek Consensus Rankings Voting Thread: QUARTERBACKS

[Fumbleweed 426]

Back for another year, the Geek Consensus Rankings are upon us. Please use this thread to vote for your top 20 QBs for the 2008 season- redraft. Standard Performance League/FF Today scoring should be used to rank the players- NO PPR! Voting will last until 10:00 PM CDT on Wednesday, 8/13, at which time voting will be closed and results tabulated. Traditional polling measures will be used to determine the results.

 

Thanks in advance for your participation! I hope this proves to be a helpful resource in establishing a solid consensus baseline for your upcoming drafts!

[Fumbleweed 426]

Here's a Top 20 to get things started:

 

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Tony Romo

4. Drew Brees

5. Carson Palmer

6. Ben Roethlisberger

7. Derek Anderson

8. Matt Hasselbeck

9. Donovan McNabb

10. Jay Cutler

11. Eli Manning

12. Marc Bulger

13. David Garrard

14. Philip Rivers

15. Brett Favre

16. Jake Delhomme

17. Matt Schaub

18. Aaron Rodgers

19. Vince Young

20. Jon Kitna

[WhiteWonder 2,171]

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Drew Brees

4. Tony Romo

5. Ben Roethlisberger

6. Carson Palmer

7. Donavan McNabb

8. Matt Hasselback

9. Jay Cutler

10. Derek Anderson

11. Eli Manning

12. Brett Favre

13. Jake Delhomme

14. David Garrard

15. Marc Bulger

16. Phillip Rivers

17. Jon Kitna

18. Matt Leinart

19. Matt Schaub

20. Vince Young

[xandermoss 0]

My top 20 QB for the Geek Poll

1.Brady

2.Manning

3.Romo

4.Brees

5.Palmer

6.D Anderson

7.Hasselbeck

8.Rothlisberger

9.Mcnabb

10.Favre

11.Bulger

12.Cutler

13.Schaub

14.Delhomme

15.Manning

16.Rodgers

17.Garrard

18.Leinart

19.V.Young

20.Rivers

[The Phantom of FFToday 0]

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Tony Romo

4. Drew Brees

5. Carson Palmer

6. Derek Anderson

7. Ben Roethlisberger

8. Donovan McNabb

9. Marc Bulger

10. Brett Favre

11. Matt Hasselbeck

12. Jay Cutler

13. David Garrard

14. Eli Manning

15. Jake Delhomme

16. Matt Shaub

17. Phillip Rivers

18. Jason Campbell

19. Vince Young

20. Aaron Rogers

[Pocket Pair Professor 0]

1- Brady

2- Romo

3- P Manning

4- Palmer

5- Brees

6- Rothesberger

7- E Manning

8- Cutler

9- Hasselback

10- McNabb

11- Delhomme

12- Garrard

13- Anderson

14- Campbell

15- Rivers

16- Farve

17- Rodgers

18- Young

19- Kitna

20- Bulger

[Bbleehehh9 0]

Here's how I have them..

 

1) Brady

2) Manning

3) Romo

4) Brees

 

5) Palmer

6) Roethlisberger

7) Anderson

8) Hasselbeck

9) McNabb

 

10) Cutler

11) Garrard

12) Bulger

13) E. Manning

 

14) Delhomme

15) Schaub

16) Favre

17) Rivers

18) Rodgers

 

19) Kitna

20) V. Young

[Jackson Biggs 0]

1. Romo

2. Brees

3. P. Manning

4. Brady

5. McNabb

6. Palmer

7. Anderson

8. Hasselbeck

9. Cutler

10. Schaub

11. Garrard

12. E. Manning

13. Ben Roth

14. Bulger

15. Leinart

16. Vince Young

17. Favre

18. Delhomme

19. Kitna

20. Rivers

[big D 0]

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Drew Brees

4. Tony Romo

5. Carson Palmer

6. Ben Roethlisberger

7. Jay Cutler

8. Matt Hasselbeck

9. Donovan McNabb

10. Derek Anderson

11. Eli Manning

12. Marc Bulger

13. Philip Rivers

14. Matt Schaub

15. Jason Campball

16. Brett Favre

17. Jon Kitna

18. Jake Delhomme

18. David Garrard

20. Vince Young

[Grizzly 0]

1 Tom Brady NE

2 Peyton Manning IND

3 Tony Romo DAL

4 Drew Brees NO

5 Carson Palmer CIN

6 Derek Anderson CLE

7 Ben Roethlisberger PIT

8 Jay Cutler DEN

9 David Garrard JAC

10 Donovan McNabb PHI

11 Matt Hasselbeck SEA

12 Matt Schaub HOU

13 Eli Manning NYG

14 Philip Rivers SD

15 Brett Favre NYJ

16 Vince Young TEN

17 Marc Bulger STL

18 Jason Campbell WAS

19 Aaron Rodgers GB

20 Jon Kitna DET

[Bishop82 61]

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Drew Brees

4. Tony Romo

5. Ben Roethlisberger

6. Carson Palmer

7. Matt Hasselbeck

8. Jay Cutler

9. Donovan McNabb

10. David Garrard

11. Eli Manning

12. Derek Anderson

13. Philip Rivers

14. Jake Delhomme

15. Marc Bulger

16. Brett Favre

17. Jon Kitna

18. Matt Schaub

19. Kurt Warner

20. Vince Young

[Super Cubs 132]

1. Peyton Manning

2. Drew Brees

3. Tom Brady

4. Tony Romo

5. Ben Roethlisberger

6. Matt Hasselbeck

7. Carson Palmer

8. Jay Cutler

9. David Garrard

10. Derek Anderson

11. Marc Bulger

12. Brett Favre

13. Matt Schaub

14. Donovan McNabb

15. Eli Manning

16. Jon Kitna

17. Jake Delhomme

18. Phillip Rivers

19. Kurt Warner

20. Aaron Rogers

[LosBucaneros 0]

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Drew Brees

4. Tony Romo

5. Carson Palmer

6. Derek Anderson

7. Donovan McNabb

8. Ben Roethlisberger

9. Matt Hasselbeck

10. Eli Manning

11. David Garrard

12. Brett Favre

13. Jake Delhomme

14. Jay Cutler

15. Matt Schaub

16. Marc Bulger

17. Philip Rivers

18. Jason Campbell

19. Jon Kitna

20. Jeff Garcia

[tom-dog1 0]

1. Peyton Manning

2. Tom Brady

3. Drew Brees

4. Ben Roethlisberger

5. Tony Romo

6. Carson Palmer

7. Donovan McNabb

8. Eli Manning

9. Philip Rivers

10. Derek Anderson

11. Matt Hasselbeck

12. Jason Campbell

13. Jay Cutler

14. Marc Bulger

15. Aaron Rodgers

16. Brett Favre

17. David Garrard

18. Matt Schaub

19. Jake Delhomme

20. Jon Kitna

[FeelingMN 273]

1. Brady

2. Manning

3. Brees

4. Romo

5. Roethlisberger

6. Palmer

7. McNabb

8. Hasselbeck

9. Cutler

10. Anderson

11. Garrard

12. Delhomme

13. Manning

14. Rivers

15. Schaub

16. Kitna

17. Rodgers

18. Bulger

19. Favre

20. Campbell

[RLLD 3,455]

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Tony Romo

4. Drew Brees

5. Carson Palmer

6. Ben Roethlisberger

7. Derek Anderson

8. Matt Hasselbeck

9. Eli Manning

10. David Garrard

11. Philip Rivers

12. Jake Delhomme

13. Marc Bulger

14. Jay Cutler

15. Brett Favre

16. Donovan McNabb

17. Matt Schaub

18. Aaron Rodgers

19. Vince Young

20. Jon Kitna

[MSin 0]

1 Tom Brady

2 Peyton Manning

3 Tony Romo

4 Drew Brees

5 Carson Palmer

6 Derek Anderson

7 Jay Cutler

8 Marc Bulger

9 Donovan McNabb

10 David Garrard

11 Ben Roethlisberger

12 Jake Delhomme

13 Matt Hasselbeck

14 Matt Schaub

15 Jon Kitna

16 Vince Young

17 Philip Rivers

18 Eli Manning

19 Brett Favre

20 Jason Campbell

[treewarden 1]

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Tony Romo

4. Drew Brees

5. Carson Palmer

6. Ben Roethlisberger

7. Donovan McNabb

8. Matt Hasselbeck

9. Derek Anderson

10. Jay Cutler

11. Matt Schaub

12. Philip Rivers

13. David Garrard

14. Aaron Rodgers

15. Brett Favre

16. Marc Bulger

17. Jake Delhomme

18. Jason Campbell

19. Eli Manning

20. Jon Kitna

[Sgt_Russia 0]

1. Peyton Manning

2. Tom Brady

3. Drew Brees

4. Tony Romo

5. Carson Palmer

6. Donovan McNabb

7. Ben Roethlisberger

8. Matt Hasselbeck

9. Derek Anderson

10. Jay Cutler

11. David Garrard

12. Philip Rivers

13. Jake Delhomme

14. Brett Favre

15. Marc Bulger

16. Matt Schaub

17. Eli Manning

18. Jon Kitna

19. Vince Young

20. Kurt Warner

[montana 89]

Mine:

 

1. Brady

2. P.Manning

3. Romo

4. Brees

5. Palmer

6. Anderson

7. Big Ben

8. Hass

9. McNabb

10. Garrard

11. Favre

12. Bulger

13. Delhomme

14. Cutler

15. Rivers

16. Kitna

17. Schaub

18. Campbell

19. Rodgers

20. Young

[Candygram4Mongo 8]

1. Brady

2. Peyton

3. Romo

4. Brees

 

5. Palmer

6. Ben

7. McNabb

8. Hass

9. Anderson

 

10. Cutler

11. Favre

12. Bulger

13. Delhomme

14. Eli

15. Gerrard

16. Shaub

17. Rivers

18. Kitna

19. TEdwards

20. Campbell

[9-Route 0]

1-manning

2-romo

3-brees

4-anderson

5-brady

6-palmer

7-hasselbeck

8-favre

9-v young

10-garrard

11-roethlisberger

12-leinart

13-campbell

14-cutler

15-t jackson

16-mcfagg

17-eli

18-kitna

19-bulger

20-croyle

 

[no, i'm not trying to skew the averages; yes, i do have tjax and croyle in my top20; no, i do not have rivers or delhomme in my top20, as i feel they along with mcfagg and bulger will have health issues.]

[Saturday Night Beaver 2]

1-Tom Brady

2-Peyton Manning

3-Tony Romo

4-Drew Brees

5-Carson Palmer

6-B.Roethlisberger

7-D. McNabb

8-David Garrard

9-D.Anderson

10- Jay Cutler

11-M. Hasselbeck

12- Brett Favre

13- Eli Manning

14- Philip Rivers

15- J. Delhomme

16- Vince Young

17- Matt Schaub

18- Marc Bulger

19- Aaron Rodgers

20- J. Campbell

[GreatGray 2]

1. Tom Brady

2. Drew Brees

3. Peyton Manning

4. Tony Romo

5. Ben Roethlisberger

6. Derek Anderson

7. Donavan McNabb

8. Carson Palmer

9. Matt Hasselback

10. Jay Cutler

11. Eli Manning

12. Aaron Rodgers

13. Jake Delhomme

14. David Garrard

15. Matt Schaub

16. John Kitna

17. Philip Rivers

18. Brett Favre

19. Marc Bulger

20. Matt Leinart

[Doc J 0]

1 Manning

2 Brady

3 Brees

4 Romo

5 D. Anderson

6 Palmer

7 Cutler

8 McNabb

9 Roethlisberger

10 Bulger

11 Delhomme

12 Garrard

13 Rivers

14 hasselback

15 Manning

16 Rodgers

17 V. Young

18 Kitna

19 Schaub

20 J. Cambell

[mtnman32 0]

1. Brady

2. Manning

 

3. Brees

4. Romo

5. Palmer

6. Anderson

 

7. Roethlisberger

8. McNabb

9. Bulger

10. Favre

 

11. Delhomme

12. Cutler

13. Manning

14. Campbell

15. Rivers

16. Hasselbeck

17. Garrard

 

18. Schaub

19. Kitna

20. Rodgers

[PistonSteve 0]

1. Tom Brady

2. Tony Romo

3. Peyton Manning

4. Drew Brees

5. Carson Palmer

6. Ben Roethlisberger

7. Derek Anderson

8. Jay Cutler

9. Jon Kitna

10. David Garrard

11. Donovan McNabb

12. Matt Hasselbeck

13. Philip Rivers

14. Matt Schaub

15. Brett Favre

16. Eli Manning

17. Jason Campbell

18. Marc Bulger

19. Vince Young

20. Matt Leinart

[kmbryant09 1]

1. Peyton Manning

2. Tom Brady

3. Drew Brees

4. Tony Romo

5. Carson Palmer

6. Derek Anderson

7. Ben Roethlisberger

8. Matt Hasselbeck

9. Eli Manning

10. Marc Bulger

11. Jake Delhomme

12. Philip Rivers

13. Jon Kitna

14. Matt Schaub

15. Jay Cutler

16. David Garrard

17. Aaron Rodgers

18. Donovan McNabb

19. Jason Cambpell

20. Matt Ryan

[barrett 0]

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Drew Brees

4. Tony Romo

5. Carson Palmer

6. Ben Roethlisberger

7. Matt Hasselbeck

8. Derek Anderson

9. Jay Cutler

10. David Garrard

11. Donovan McNabb

12. Marc Bulger

13. Eli Manning

14. Matt Schaub

15. Philip Rivers

16. Brett Favre

17. Jake Delhomme

18. Aaron Rodgers

19. Vince Young

20. Jason Campbell

[Phurfur 70]

1. Brady, Tom

2. Manning, Peyton

3. Romo, Tony

4. Roethlisberger, Ben

5. Brees, Drew

6. Hasselbeck, Matt

7. Anderson, Derek

8. Palmer, Carson

9. Bulger, Marc

10. Favre, Brett

11. McNabb, Donovan

12. Garrard, David

13. Delhomme, Jake

14. Schaub, Matt

15. Cutler, Jay

16. Manning, Eli

17. Rivers, Philip

18. Rodgers, Aaron

19. Campbell, Jason

20. Garcia, Jeff

[Magoo14322 0]

1. Tom Brady

2. Tony Romo

3. Peyton Manning

4. Drew Brees

5. Carson Palmer

6. Ben Roethlisberger

7. Donovan McNabb

8. Matt Hasselbeck

9. Matt Schaub

10. David Garrard

11. Philip Rivers

12. Derek Anderson

13. Marc Bulger

14. Eli Manning

15. Jay Cutler

16. Jake Delhomme

17. Aaron Rodgers

18. Vince Young

19. Jason Campbell

20. Matt Leinart

[freighttrain 0]

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Tony Romo

4. Drew Brees

5. Carson Palmer

6. Ben Roethlisberger

7. Matt Hasselbeck

8. Jake Delhomme

9. Derek Anderson

10. Donovan McNabb

11. Brett Favre

12. Jay Cutler

13.Aaron Rodgers

14. David Garrard

15. Eli Manning

16. Jon Kitna

17. Matt Leinart

18. Vince Young

19. Jason Campbell

20. Kurt Warner

[MarcM85 0]

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Tony Romo

4. Drew Brees

5. Ben Roethlisberger

6. Carson Palmer

7. Derek Anderson

8. Matt Hasselbeck

9. Donovan McNabb

10. Jay Cutler

11. Marc Bulger

12. David Garrard

13. Brett Favre

14. Eli Manning

15. Jake Delhomme

16. Philip Rivers

17. Matt Schaub

18. Aaron Rodgers

19. Matt Leinart

20. Vince Young

[Byars41 0]

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Drew Brees

4. Tony Romo

5. Carson Palmer

6. Ben Roethlisberger

7. Derek Anderson

8. Donovan McNabb

9. Brett Favre

10. Aaron Rodgers

11. Philip Rivers

12. Matt Schaub

13. David Garrard

14. Matt Hasselbeck

15. Marc Bulger

16. Jay Cutler

16. Eli Manning

17. Matt Leinart

18. Jake Delhomme

19. Jason Campbell

20. Jon Kitna

[carmo911 2]

1. Tom Brady

2. Payton Manning

3. Drew Brees

4. Tony Romo

5. Carson Palmer

6. Donovan McNabb

7. Ben Roethlisberger

8. Matt Schaub

9. Brett Favre

10. Derek Anderson

11. Jay Culter

12. Phillip Rivers

13. Matt Hasselback

14. David Garrard

15. Eli Manning

16. Jason Campbell

17. Aaron Rodgers

18. Jake Delhomme

19. Jon Kitna

20. Marc Bulger

[bigfische 0]

1) Tom Brady QB NE

 

2) Peyton manning QB IND

 

3) Tony Romo QB DAL

 

4) Drew Brees QB NO

 

5) Carson palmer QB CIN

 

6) Ben Rothlisberger QB PIT

 

7) Derek Anderson QB CLE

 

8) Matt Hasselback QB SEA

 

9) Donovan Mcnabb QB PHI

 

10) Marc Bulger QB STL

 

11) Jay Cutler QB DEN

 

12) Eli manning QB NYG

 

13) Jake Delhomme QB CAR

 

14) David Garrard QB JAC

 

15) Brett Favre OB NYJ

 

16) Philip Rivers QB SD

 

17) Jon Kitna QB DET

 

18) Matt Schaub QB HOU

 

19) Aaron Rodgers QB GB

 

20) Jason Campbell QB WAS

[myjimmy1 0]

01) Tom Brady

02) Peyton Brady

03) Tony Romo

04) Drew Brees

05) Carson Palmer

06) Ben Roethlisberger

07) Derek Anderson

08) Matt Hasselbeck

09) Donavan McNabb

10) Brett Favre

11) Marc Bulger

12) David Garrard

13) Jay Cutler

14) Eli Manning

15) Phillip Rivers

16) Jake Delhomme

17) Matt Shaub

18) Jon Kitna

19) Aaron Rodgers

20) Jason Campbell

[Mike FF Today 607]

1. Tom Brady NE

2. Peyton Manning IND

3. Tony Romo DAL

4. Drew Brees NO

5. Ben Roethlisberger PIT

6. Derek Anderson CLE

7. Carson Palmer CIN

8. Donovan McNabb PHI

9. Jay Cutler DEN

10. David Garrard JAC

11. Matt Schaub HOU

12. Matt Hasselbeck SEA

13. Aaron Rodgers GB

14. Jon Kitna DET

15. Vince Young TEN

16. Philip Rivers SD

17. Brett Favre NYJ

18. Eli Manning NYG

19. Marc Bulger STL

20. Jason Campbell WAS