who would u pick up...plummer or leinart?

[truereligion 0]

leinart should have more upside, but also a higher risk. what do u think?

[Springfield Isotopes 0]

Plummer absolutely, positively no question...

 

Here is mine

[jfladien 0]

Depends on who your other QBs are...if you are solid at QB, I say take a flyer on Leinart...who knows with those weapons around him.

 

If it's between these two guys for your starting QB, then take Jake. But I agree, Leinart has more upside IMO.

 

Here is mine.

 

Thanks.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=237595

[gold_finger 0]

For the next few weeks I'd definitely take Plummer as a starter but if you have a roster spot then Leinart might be big in the long run with Edge, Boldin, and Fitzgerald as weapons. But Leinart is a rookie and I don't see him playing that well in his first couple games. Good luck.

[Melvinbet 5]

Leinart looked very good in preseason but then again so did the Raiders. If you have a really good QB already then go ahead and pick him up. If your looking for someone to play this week, Plummer is on a bye.

 

Here's mine

[truereligion 0]

i have delhomme and bulger but need to start 2, who tp pick up...plummer ot leinart?

[Melvinbet 5]

For this week?

[truereligion 0]

not this week in particular...as u know bulger and delhomme are not doing as good as they should be, so i am trying to add depth at QB

[seattleslew 0]

Leinart may turn out to be a good QB by the end of the year, but fact is he hasn't taken a snap in a regular game.

 

Go with Plummer. He will face some soft Ds in weeks ahead.

 

Thanks for seeing mine.

[Melvinbet 5]

Ya, if you want to play it safe you better go with Plummer.

[golden bear 0]

As much as I hate to say it, you've gotta take Plummer. I know it isn't easy to insert Jake into your lineup right now, but like everyone said, you can't be putting too much trust in a Rookie QB, they just don't do well in their first year.

[truereligion 0]

i know...it's just that there are so much hype about leinart (him being the most ready ever, love by his teammates etc etc...) besides, how often do we say plummer is a "safer" pick?

[Ray_T 786]

well, right now I'd take the guy with the Starting job. (plummer)

 

Lienert can have all the potential he wants, but if plummer goes out and plays well for the rest of the season, Lienert wont get to play much.

 

now, on the other hand if Plummer goes and stinks the joint out again, all bets are off.

 

but for now, I'd take plummer.

[Niners_fan 0]

Plummer.