t1m

Thanks for the reply. WR is where I really would like a more solid #2, and probably should have tried to lock one down earlier in the draft. I might have to try and get creative w/ some trades here. I went with McNabb early to try and lock up some consistency for the OP spot. Not the most popular decision, I know.

Hey all, Rate my team, and if you want to throw in a link to yours and I'll rate you 12 teams, non PPR, 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 1 OP (RB/WR/QB/TE), 1 K, 1 D/ST It was an 8 team league last year, and we expanded by 4. Each team from last year got to pick 1 keeper for a pick in the round he was drafted last year, costing a minimum of a 5th round pick. For example, a player drafted in the 3rd round last year would cost a third round pick this year. A player drafted from the 5th round on, though, would all cost a 5th round pick. The 8 Players kept: LT, AP, Brady, Moss, Romo, Wayne, sJax, & I kept Braylon in the 5th. I drew # 1 My Team QB: Big Ben McNabb RB: Westbrook McGahee (cuffed w/ Rice) Jonathan Stewart Maurice Morris WR: Braylon Edwards Santana Moss Reggie Brown Derick Mason D.J. Hackett TE: Tony Scheffler Greg Olsen D/ST: Seattle K: Shane Graham Starting (for now) Q:Big Ben RB: Westbrook, McGahee WR: Braylon, S. Moss TE: Scheffler OP: McNabb D/ST: Seattle K: Shayne Graham Thanks!!

Pretty good, but I'm also curious how many teams in the league. Also, why 2 def? You could have tried to fill in the gaps for RB or WR there, for example trying to cuff McGahee is Rice were still available. I'm not always sold on handcuffing, but with McG, Rice is a solid cuff (though I am biased on that one: see My Team ).

If you have the option to only start 1 RB, I'd say go for the trade. Braylon has a good shot to end the season as the #1 or #2 WR in the league, with some of that of course depending on Anderson. Overall, solid team. The RB situation would worry me though. Better hope some of the sleepers pan out.

I'd agree about the QB. Being able to start McNabb as the OP was what made up my mind. My big question is whether Moss will pan out for me as a #2 WR. Brown, Mason or Hackett could end up with his spot, depending on how well Moss fits into the Washington system.

Whitten in the 3rd is a little suspicious, but you certainly have you based covered for the DAL O. Where's Romo?

As was mentioned, depends on the size of the league, and you might want to keep an eye on your WR corps, but overall pretty solid. My team for rating: http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=320113

Hey all, Rate my team, and if you want to throw in a link to yours and I'll rate you 12 teams, non PPR, 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 1 OP (RB/WR/QB/TE), 1 K, 1 D/ST It was an 8 team league last year, and we expanded by 4. Each team from last year got to pick 1 keeper for a pick in the round he was drafted last year, costing a minimum of a 5th round pick. For example, a player drafted in the 3rd round last year would cost a third round pick this year. A player drafted from the 5th round on, though, would all cost a 5th round pick. The 8 Players kept: LT, AP, Brady, Moss, Romo, Wayne, sJax, & I kept Braylon in the 5th. I drew # 1 My Team QB: Big Ben McNabb RB: Westbrook McGahee (cuffed w/ Rice) Jonathan Stewart Maurice Morris WR: Braylon Edwards Santana Moss Reggie Brown Derick Mason D.J. Hackett TE: Tony Scheffler Greg Olsen D/ST: Seattle K: Shane Graham Starting (for now) Q:Big Ben RB: Westbrook, McGahee WR: Braylon, S. Moss TE: Scheffler OP: McNabb D/ST: Seattle K: Shayne Graham

I say Len.

If we go ppr it will definitely make my choice easier.

Well, I have 2 weeks to decide.

Addai also looks good in terms of playoff match-ups compared to Westbrook.

Cool. What do you think w/o the ppr?

12 team league. New teams were just brought on board, and all 8 teams who stayed each got to pick one keeper, forfeiting a draft pick in the round the player was picked last year (anybody picked in or after the 5th round costs a 5th round pick). I'm keeping Braylon Edwards for a 5th round pick. The other 7 players kept are: LT A. Peterson Brady Romo Moss S. Jackson R. Wayne I have the first pick in the draft, and then 24th and 25th. Who do I take as #1? I'm leaning Westbrook. Here is our current scoring, and there is discussion of adding a point per reception. Passing Every 25 passing yards 1 TD Pass 4 40+ yard TD pass bonus 2 Interceptions Thrown -2 2pt Passing Conversion 2 Rushing Every 10 rushing yards 1 TD Rush 6 40+ yard TD rush bonus 2 2pt Rushing Conversion 2 Receiving Every 10 receiving yards 1 TD Reception 6 40+ yard TD rec bonus 2 2pt Receiving Conversion 2 If we add a point per reception, Westbrook looks even better. What say you all?