Can Maddux keep up the hot start?

[Thin Spirit 0]

I'm being offered Maddux straight up for Sizemore in a redraft league.

 

Sizemore has started slow, Maddux has started hot. Do you think it will even out, or would you do the trade?

 

20 team league, basic rotisserie scoring

 

C - R Hernandez

1B - D Ortiz

2B - M Lowell

3B - R Zimmerman

SS - C Barmes

OF - G Sizemore

OF - B Hawpe

OF - R Church

OF - W Pena

Util - K Youkilis

BN - C Koskie

DL - I Kinsler

DL - R Baldelli

DL - C Crisp

 

SP - J Schmidt

SP - C Lee

SP - M Clement

SP - Od Perez

RP - B Lidge

RP - B Jenks

P - Ol Perez

P - A Cook

P - S Williamson

BN - T Armas

 

If Crisp and Baldelli were healthy and playing on a regular basis, I think I would do this trade...but I havent heard reports on either player in a long while.

[BuckeyeMiniMe 0]

You are pretty thin in the OF. Because of that, I would be patient with Sizemore. Until the Cubs start hitting, the Wins may be scarce for Maddux. The ERA and WHIP should be good. He was never very strong at K's so you figure that you are strong in two categories. Sizemore should be strong in 3 categories; AVG, RUNS, and SB. I would stay with Sizemore...IMO.