imagine 3 years from now...who would you rather have...and why?

[semaj33 0]

thanks for your consideration...

[famousb 11]

i had to go Carr and Miller.

I think Carr is slowly maturing into a decent QB as his team gets better around him. If he ever had a season where he wasn't sacked every other play he may actually complete some passes.

I also think we've seen the best of Vick unless he can learn to throw w/ some touch and finesse. His best running days are behind him, so like McNabb before him, now he has to learn to throw the ball instead of just scrambling constantly. IF he could learn to actually be a legit passer, i think he could be good, but from a pure passer standpoint, i'm going Carr for potential...

 

Then Miller v. Cooley. I think Cooley is good, but there are too many options in the O now, and Cooley wasn't always getting the looks last year (was it Betts that they'd also throw in there for the same type player?). Miller is young, with a young QB, and has go-to-guy potential in the redzone - which is where it really matters for a TE.

[Force of Two 0]

i had to go Carr and Miller.

I think Carr is slowly maturing into a decent QB as his team gets better around him. If he ever had a season where he wasn't sacked every other play he may actually complete some passes.

I also think we've seen the best of Vick unless he can learn to throw w/ some touch and finesse. His best running days are behind him, so like McNabb before him, now he has to learn to throw the ball instead of just scrambling constantly. IF he could learn to actually be a legit passer, i think he could be good, but from a pure passer standpoint, i'm going Carr for potential...

 

Then Miller v. Cooley. I think Cooley is good, but there are too many options in the O now, and Cooley wasn't always getting the looks last year (was it Betts that they'd also throw in there for the same type player?). Miller is young, with a young QB, and has go-to-guy potential in the redzone - which is where it really matters for a TE.

 

I couldnt agree more with this analysis other than I still think the guy (Vick) can run but in three years that might not be the case

[bdill77 0]

I think Heath Miller has a lot more upside than Cooley does, and I think Carr will turn into a fine NFL QB. Vick's a great athlete, but I don't know if he will ever get a lot better. Once age kicks in he will have a problem, or maybe it will make him a better passer.

[Cuse9 129]

I don't care for Vick, but Cooley is better than any of the other three.

 

Miller is in Pitt, while he did respectable last year, he had alot of nothing games. Carr has a better chance to become a good fantasy qb than Vick, but either way those two should only be back ups. Cooley is a starter easily.

[OriginalMonkeyBoy 0]

Carr and Miller. Personally, I think Carr has gotton a pass for his poor performance. Vick would give you more points, provided he doesn't get hurt (which is a huge possibility). However, Heath Miller is HUGE. IMHO

[biglou 2]

I believe Carr will do nothing except become a top 5 QB in that system. If Kubiak can turn around Plummer's carreer just think what he will be able to with Carr. Miller will be depended on more with loss of Randle El and with Holmes' problems. Cooley will be depended on less with the arrivial of all the recievers in a run heavy offense.

[Wildman 0]

I believe Carr will do nothing except become a top 5 QB in that system. If Kubiak can turn around Plummer's carreer just think what he will be able to with Carr. Miller will be depended on more with loss of Randle El and with Holmes' problems. Cooley will be depended on less with the arrivial of all the recievers in a run heavy offense.

 

Carr over Vick...

 

I live near ATL and the whispers are Vick doesn't work hard enough, he's immature, and isn't the swiftest as a student of the game. This guy is one bad knee injury away from being a below average QB unless he develops his passing beyond the level he's at right now.

[Artowis 0]

I have to say Carr, because it truly seems like he's a decent QB who just gets smashed every year. I actually think he does quite well for what little he has to work with, unlike other QB's like Losman and Harrington. Carr has potential and work ethic, Vick has potential and laziness (Way to only pass when people ###### about it).

 

I think famousb summed up the Heath vs. Cooley thing.

[Los Angeles Raiders of Oakland 0]

I would go with Vick.

 

There is always a sucker in the leauge that will overpay for him. I look forward to it every year. He's got Sex appeal someone will bite.