Which team would you rather have?

[TexansWinSB 0]

Which one do you want?

 

KEEPER LEAGUE and PPR - 1 pt/10 yds rush ; 1 pt/15 yds receiving ; all TDs = 6 pts ; 1 pt/25 yds passing

 

Start: QB, RB, RB/WR, WR, WR, TE, Def, K

 

Option A

 

Plummer

S. Alexander

Rudi Johnson

Westbrook

Chad Johnson

Andre Johnson

Lavaraneus Colest

 

OR

 

Option B

 

McNabb or Bulger

Cadillac Williams

Rudi Johnson

Westbrook

Reggie Wayne

Darrell Jackson

Andre Johnson

[Badmojo1006 0]

Option A

 

QB - McNabb is a little better than Plummer

 

RB - Alexander is MUCH better than C. Williams

 

WR - Johnson and Coles are slightly less than Wayne and D. Jackson

 

On the strength of Alexander, I would go with Team A

[lguero1 4]

sa and chad make the team. plummer will be fine this year.

[Ignignokt 0]

Yup, A looks stronger.

[akareckas 0]

Ok so this really boils down to

 

Plummer/Alexander/CJ/Coles vs McNabb/Caddy/Wayne/DJ

 

When I look at this it seems obvious. Go with Alexander. You always want to be the guy that gets the best single player. To add to the obviousness you also get teh 2nd best player (CJ) going this route.

 

As for any argument about the QB...who cares? The difference between SA and Caddy will be astronomical compared to the difference between Plummer and McNabb. Moreover, Plummer will probably play 16 games whereas McNabb will play 5 awesome games 6 pedestrian games 2 half games and sit for the other 3 (I'm an Eagles fan, ignore the bitterness).