Trade Help - deciding between 2 blockbuster trades

[dpollaro 0]

Just drafted tonight ..had the 9 spot

 

i acquired ronnie for peyton during the draft..but now want peyton back...see below

 

10 team league

 

6 pts for all tds

1 pt for 50 yards passing, 1 pt for 10 yds rushing/receiving

 

start

 

1qb

2 rb

2wr

1 te

1k

1def

3 flex (rb,wr,te)

 

my current team

 

qb: bledsoe, warner, mcnair

rb: ronnie brown, caddilac, jamal lewis, addai, chris brwon, michael bennet, travis henry

wr: santana, andre johnson, stallworth, toomer, cedrick wilson, stokley

te: heap, witten (gonna start both of them)

k: vanderjadt

def: atlanta

 

my startin lineup now

 

 

bledsoe / warner / mcnair

ronnie brown

caddy

santana

andre johnson

heap

witten

addai / chris brown

jamal lewis

vanderjadt

atlanta

 

2 trades on the table

 

1st trade

i give ronnie brown, bledsoe, kurt warner

i get peyton manning, aaron brooks, kevan barlow (hopefully trade him for mike anderson in a later deal)

 

my starting lineup would look like:

peyton

caddy

jamal lewis

santana

andrejohnson

heap

witten

chris brown

joseph addai

vanderjadt

atlanta

 

 

2nd trade

 

i give caddy and andre johnson

i get terrell owens and roy williams

 

My starting lineup would look like:

 

bledsoe / warner / mcnair

ronnie brown

jamal lewis

terrel owens

santana moss

witten

roy williams

addai/chris brown

vanderjadt

atlanta

 

 

DO you like these trades for me? which team do you like best out of the 3 scenarios

 

Please leave your thoughts

[PistolPete2432 0]

I personally would not do either of the trades especially the 2nd trade

[rottytiny 7]

I like getting Owens and Williams. Then trade one of your WR's or TE's for an upgrade at RB if possible. Brown is in a bad spot in Tenn. Addai should get a shot towards the middle of the season but who knows.

 

Good luck.

[skittles 0]

Id probably do the second trade, if any. RBs and WRs will run your league, because of the yardage they have over the quarterbacks. QBs will be higher value based on total touchdowns, which makes Manning quite a better pick than your current crop, in my opinion.

 

However, I think getting rid of Ronnie Brown is a bad idea here. I dont mind you getting rid of Cadillac quite as much, and love the acquisition of both Owens and Williams, who could both start for you depending on how the Skins system is working out. I see alot of Portis, and Cooley when the ball is in the air.

 

Anyway, you dont NEED to make either of these deals. However, you could use improvement at WR, and I think a starting backfield of Brown and Lewis is perfectly acceptable when you have Owens and Williams in your arsenal as well.

[philly81 0]

Do not give up Ronnie Brown. My draft is not untill 9/2, and I would be estatic to have him on my roster. I really like Kurt Warner. Look at the receivers he has! I know his offensive line is questionable. I still think he will have a good year. I would stay pat!

[FBH ** 0]

I would not make either move at this point. I like the second deal much better than the first but not enough to take it at this point. At this point you don't know what you will get from JLew, and you can't sacrifice RB depth just yet. You would also be getting back two guys with checkered pasts, who knows when TO will blow up an entire franchise and when Roy will blow out his ankle. If you see JLew do well in some preseason action then I would consider it, but wait until you know what to expect from him.

[badmonkey 0]

Do whaterver you can not to start a TE in your 3rd flex position. YUCK

[OriginalMonkeyBoy 0]

thanks for answering mine.

 

I have to agree with the majority, here. Stay where you're at. Warner should be fine for a while, and you can use the WW to look for another QB.

[enjoi525 0]

ya, don't do any of the trades.