sae_1856 0 Posted September 1, 2006 Had our draft last night and I have some possible trades to make. League is 14 teams with pretty standard scoring (-2 for fumbles/ints, +1 per catch, everything else is normal). I have been offered Joseph Addai for Laurence Maroney. This is my #4 RB. I am thinking about offering Willis McGahee for Clinton Portis. This is my #1 RB. Do I drop Oakland QB and pick up Tampa Bay QB or Detroit QB? I have Miami QB as my starter. We use team QB instead of individuals. Any thoughts are appreciated. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Dano_mano 0 Posted September 1, 2006 Had our draft last night and I have some possible trades to make. League is 14 teams with pretty standard scoring (-2 for fumbles/ints, +1 per catch, everything else is normal). I have been offered Joseph Addai for Laurence Maroney. This is my #4 RB. I am thinking about offering Willis McGahee for Clinton Portis. This is my #1 RB. Do I drop Oakland QB and pick up Tampa Bay QB or Detroit QB? I have Miami QB as my starter. We use team QB instead of individuals. Any thoughts are appreciated. Addai has far more upside with Maroney's knee, esp. if it turns out to be serious. The Rhodes question still doesn't seem to be answered, so at least Addai has a better chance. But with the knee, I'd probably have to say the trade should be invalidated unless both sides know the extent of the problem. Get Portis. Portis with a bum shoulder is still better than McGahee with a big mouth. TB QB would seem to me to be a better bet than the other 2, at least right now. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
sae_1856 0 Posted September 1, 2006 Addai has far more upside with Maroney's knee, esp. if it turns out to be serious. The Rhodes question still doesn't seem to be answered, so at least Addai has a better chance. But with the knee, I'd probably have to say the trade should be invalidated unless both sides know the extent of the problem. Get Portis. Portis with a bum shoulder is still better than McGahee with a big mouth. TB QB would seem to me to be a better bet than the other 2, at least right now. Thank you for your quick reply! It sounds like you don't like McGahee for some reason. I've heard great things about him, but I think the Washington O is gonna be much more dynamic than the Buffalo O. I'm thinking I should wait until after the first week to offer the McGahee/Portis trade. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
travis6cs 0 Posted September 1, 2006 Pull the trigger on both of these.. before they reconsider... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
