Dynasty Trade Help

[WoodDuck2003 0]

Non ppr side which you like better? We start 2-3 RBs and 3-4 WRs or TEs.

 

My RBs:

MJD/Turner/Addai/F.Jackson/J.Forsett/D.Brown/J.Snelling/R.Jennings

 

My WRs:

AJ/Megatron/Marshall/Ocho/TJ/Winslow/Coles/Walter

 

 

Addai/D.Brown/TJ/2011 1st(will be top 3 and could be 1.01)

or

Forte/Nicks

 

Lets say the worse case happens and that 1st truns out to be the 1.01 is this worth it?

[Gepetto 979]

Non ppr side which you like better? We start 2-3 RBs and 3-4 WRs or TEs.

 

My RBs:

MJD/Turner/Addai/F.Jackson/J.Forsett/D.Brown/J.Snelling/R.Jennings

 

My WRs:

AJ/Megatron/Marshall/Ocho/TJ/Winslow/Coles/Walter

Addai/D.Brown/TJ/2011 1st(will be top 3 and could be 1.01)

or

Forte/Nicks

 

Lets say the worse case happens and that 1st truns out to be the 1.01 is this worth it?

 

You don't need Nicks.

 

I like the 2011 1st pick Ingram.

[We Tigers 71]

I would stay put. WR is the last position you need to overpay for right now. Of course, this trade also depends on your view of Forte; if you think he'll rebound and become a consistent 1500 yard/12 TD guy, then it's a good trade for you. I think Forte's future is pretty questionable given Chester Taylor's arrival this year, the Bears' junk o-line, and the fact that Forte has yet to break 4 YPC a season. That high draft pick plus Addai (good for this year) and Brown (probably decent this year, and lots of future potential) make it too much.

[WoodDuck2003 0]

All great points guys. I am one that believes in getting Forte on the cheap but I dont think Addai/D.Brown for Forte/Taylor is "on the cheap". lol

 

Good points about not over paying for a WR either but I do like Nicks moving forward to be a consistant top 15 guy and if that pick does turn out to be the 1.01 wow would I be pissed lol

[Raider 84 29]

I wouldn't do it because of the first overall pick in the draft.

[We Tigers 71]

How do you know it's going to be top 3? Is the guy's team really, really, really terrible?

[WoodDuck2003 0]

Here is the roster, you tell me.

 

Garrard, David JAC QB

Manning, Eli NYG QB

Stafford, Matthew DET QB (P)

Bradshaw, Ahmad NYG RB (P)

Buckhalter, Correll DEN RB

Davis, James CLE RB

Williams, Carnell TBB RB

Williams, DeAngelo CAR RB (P)

Austin, Miles DAL WR

Burleson, Nate DET WR

Butler, Deon SEA WR

Doucet, Early ARI WR

Gibson, Brandon STL WR

Henderson, Devery NOS WR

Knox, Johnny CHI WR

Morgan, Josh SFO WR

Smith, Steve NYG WR

 

Picks:

1.01/1.10/2.06/3.01/3.06

So in the draft he will get one impact RB for this year. Of course some of his guys could breakout but one injury to a key player and he is toast!

 

It is a non ppr so QBs and RBs are a premium!

[We Tigers 71]

I dunno if that's a bottom-3 team in a dynasty league, but you're right in that he'll probably be fighting to get in the playoffs.

[Quickolas1 80]

giving up too much

 

i dont see forte or nicks in that roster you just posted?

[We Tigers 71]

Confused me at first too, but I figured it out: WoodDuck has that guy's 2011 pick from another trade of some sort. The pick is just another asset.

[WoodDuck2003 0]

yes the second roster I posted is the team that I got the 2011 1st rd pick from. Someone asked how I knew it would be early. I traded A.Bradshaw for his 2011 1st. My WRs are in good shape but by next year I will need an injection of young RBs and felt Bradshaw was a good move since I prob would use him this year.

 

Hopefully I have the 1st and last pick in the 1st rd next year.

 

I did not do the trade based on the responses in this post. Just hard to move Marshall for Nicks even with the upgrade at QB.