Garcon or S. Smith (CAR), Ronnie Brown for Hillis, Ward or M. Williams (SEA)?

[c_Weezie 3]

I feel like I may need a boost at RB considering the state that Torain is in, but I'm not sure if Peyton Hillis is the answer. Here's a potential trade I have on the table.

 

 

I give:

 

WR - Pierre Garcon or Steve Smith (CAR)

RB - Ronnie Brown

 

I receive:

 

RB - Peyton Hillis

WR - Hines Ward or Mike Williams (SEA)

 

 

Here's my current squad:

 

QB: Aaron Rodgers

RB: LeSean McCoy ,Ryan Torain, Ronnie Brown, Shonn Greene, Reggie Bush

WR: Roddy White, Steve Smith (CAR), Pierre Garcon, Santana Moss

TE: Jacob Tamme, Kellen Winslow

K: To be filled

D/ST: Rams

 

 

 

*Do I pull the trigger on Hillis?

*Do I give up Garcon or Smith?

*Do I take Ward or Williams?

 

 

THANK YOU, please leave a link and I WILL answer

[ckunkle 0]

Well, I like Garcon more than Smith. Even though Smith is the solid #1, Garcon has Peyton throwing him the ball. He is much more liekly to put up solid numbers every week. I dont know if he will take that trade though, he is giving up a top 10-15 RB for a top 20 (maybe) WR and a top 30 RB. But you can certainly try. I dont see you being able to get the WR (Ward or Williams) if he does do the trade. However, you can always offer and if you do I like Ward's consistency and rapport with Ben.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=375623

[c_Weezie 3]

Well, I like Garcon more than Smith. Even though Smith is the solid #1, Garcon has Peyton throwing him the ball. He is much more liekly to put up solid numbers every week. I dont know if he will take that trade though, he is giving up a top 10-15 RB for a top 20 (maybe) WR and a top 30 RB. But you can certainly try. I dont see you being able to get the WR (Ward or Williams) if he does do the trade. However, you can always offer and if you do I like Ward's consistency and rapport with Ben.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=375623

 

Thanks for the help. I'm assuming you think I should take the deal, as it's already been discussed and it's on the table. I'm leaning towards taking the deal and giving him Smith + Brown for Hillis + Ward.

[WiljenFC 0]

I'd give Smith and Brown for Hillis and Ward

 

I think with Ben Back Ward should rival Smith and Hillis is a clear upgrade over Brown.

[TV's Frank 0]

I'd hang on to Garcon, but Brown/Smith for Hillis/Ward is a great deal for you. Pull the trigger.

 

Here's mine: http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=375643

[lbforlb 1]

Yeah I also like Smith and Brown for Hillis and Ward. If you can do that take it and run.

My link