mccnavy76 6 Posted September 6 My team: QB: Prescott, G. Smith RB: Jacobs, Mixon, Dobbins, Montgomery, B. Robinson, Charbonnet WR: Jefferson, Cooper, Lockett, G. Davis TE: Kittle I've been offered D. Carr and C. Lamb for Montgomery and Smith... Definitely a WR upgrade for me but I lose backup QB and RB depth. Thoughts? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
weepaws 2,024 Posted September 6 i would take the deal. You have plenty of rb depth, good job. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
mccnavy76 6 Posted September 7 Not really...1 bonus point for every 5 receptions. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Da_Bears 10 Posted September 7 I would take the trade and get Lamb and Carr. Lamb is top 10 wr and is an excellent pairing with Jefferson. Carr is going to be a surprise with the schedule the Saints have so not a big difference than Geno. As far as RB depth, the wr value makes up for that. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Ray_T 553 Posted September 7 I would also take the deal. I think Carr will be really good this year. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
wolves111 60 Posted September 7 On 9/6/2023 at 6:22 PM, mccnavy76 said: My team: QB: Prescott, G. Smith RB: Jacobs, Mixon, Dobbins, Montgomery, B. Robinson, Charbonnet WR: Jefferson, Cooper, Lockett, G. Davis TE: Kittle I've been offered D. Carr and C. Lamb for Montgomery and Smith... Definitely a WR upgrade for me but I lose backup QB and RB depth. Thoughts? So essentially it’s Montgomery for Lamb. If I were in your league I’d challenge the trade because you clearly would be hosing this guy. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
pipeman 16 Posted September 9 Hard to make sense of the trade without seeing his roster. As it stands, it’s a no-brainer for you. If he’s weak at QB and stacked at WR, maybe he’s thinking Geno is a huge upgrade? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
mccnavy76 6 Posted September 9 I accepted the trade and we'll see who/what votes come in. He knows what he's doing...been in league for years and is always competitive. Unfortunately, he wasn't available for the draft and auto draft got him. His other QB is Richardson and he only has (2) RBs...B. Hall and A.Jones. Remaing WRs will be Hill, Hopkins, M.Brown, and Smith-Njigba. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
The Commish 2022 1 Posted September 10 14 hours ago, mccnavy76 said: I accepted the trade and we'll see who/what votes come in. He knows what he's doing...been in league for years and is always competitive. Unfortunately, he wasn't available for the draft and auto draft got him. His other QB is Richardson and he only has (2) RBs...B. Hall and A.Jones. Remaing WRs will be Hill, Hopkins, M.Brown, and Smith-Njigba. Sorry I'm late to the response, since you have accepted. I personally would have countered with JK vs Montgomery. JK is always hurt but maybe you could have offloaded him for Lamb. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
mccnavy76 6 Posted September 10 6 hours ago, The Commish 2022 said: Sorry I'm late to the response, since you have accepted. I personally would have countered with JK vs Montgomery. JK is always hurt but maybe you could have offloaded him for Lamb. Admittedly, I did consider that....and with my luck, he probabaly will get hurt (sorry Ravens fans:)). On the other hand, Montgomery has gotten dinged up in the past too (so has Mixon) and I'd read that Gibbs is supposed to be good...therefore, that could eat into some of his value. In the next few weeks I'll definitely be looking at the waiver wire to see what rookie or backup can help me with depth...for RB and QB. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
The Commish 2022 1 Posted September 10 4 hours ago, mccnavy76 said: Admittedly, I did consider that....and with my luck, he probabaly will get hurt (sorry Ravens fans:)). On the other hand, Montgomery has gotten dinged up in the past too (so has Mixon) and I'd read that Gibbs is supposed to be good...therefore, that could eat into some of his value. In the next few weeks I'll definitely be looking at the waiver wire to see what rookie or backup can help me with depth...for RB and QB. True.....but as someone who's had both....I can rely on Montgomery more than Dobbins to be in the line up and produce. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
mccnavy76 6 Posted September 10 2 hours ago, The Commish 2022 said: True.....but as someone who's had both....I can rely on Montgomery more than Dobbins to be in the line up and produce. Lol...you may have officially jinxed it:) Dobbins didn't even make it through the first game! Just my luck! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
The Commish 2022 1 Posted September 10 13 minutes ago, mccnavy76 said: Lol...you may have officially jinxed it:) Dobbins didn't even make it through the first game! Just my luck! LOL......you never want anyone to get injured. With that said......JK is ALWAYS hurt. He's like Tua of RB's, He's just not durable. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
The Commish 2022 1 Posted September 10 1 hour ago, mccnavy76 said: Lol...you may have officially jinxed it:) Dobbins didn't even make it through the first game! Just my luck! Wow......JK torn his achilles ......didn't see that coming. But this is the kind of results of JK. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
wolves111 60 Posted September 11 On 9/6/2023 at 6:22 PM, mccnavy76 said: My team: QB: Prescott, G. Smith RB: Jacobs, Mixon, Dobbins, Montgomery, B. Robinson, Charbonnet WR: Jefferson, Cooper, Lockett, G. Davis TE: Kittle I've been offered D. Carr and C. Lamb for Montgomery and Smith... Definitely a WR upgrade for me but I lose backup QB and RB depth. Thoughts? Well, Edwards will get 10-15 touches per game and Williams is a wild card with higher upside. I have both Dobbins and Edwards but will target Williams or Joshua Kelly of the LAC. While Edwards is a decent flex option, you're probably looking for a every week starter. Roll the dice with Williams. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
mccnavy76 6 Posted September 15 Williams and Kelley were taken...I was able to grab Edwards. Only other possible viable stashes are Achane, Warren, and Bigsby. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
