RedzoneMonster 107 Posted September 19 I have someone offering me J. Reed for guys I really don’t “need”, but like (D. Robinson and C. Steele). I feel like once both Reed and Love are 100% Reed has a shot to be a top 20 fantasy WR. Apparently the guy offering him doesn’t have the same opinion. Am I wrong here? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
weepaws 2,986 Posted September 19 Reed for, D Johnson/Steele? I would take it. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RedzoneMonster 107 Posted September 19 6 minutes ago, weepaws said: Reed for, D Johnson/Steele? I would take it. Yeah, I agree. I see Reed ranked in the “30’s” for this week and even in some “rest of the way” rankings, but I’m guessing they are a factoring in his and Love’s injuries. I don’t care if he’ll be a WR3 this week. I’m thinking rest of the way, which I could see him as a solid wr2. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
TBayXXXVII 2,378 Posted September 19 23 minutes ago, RedzoneMonster said: I have someone offering me J. Reed for guys I really don’t “need”, but like (D. Robinson and C. Steele). I feel like once both Reed and Love are 100% Reed has a shot to be a top 20 fantasy WR. Apparently the guy offering him doesn’t have the same opinion. Am I wrong here? Nope, not wrong. Robinson and Steele don't have the ceiling that Reed does. Unlike you, I don't think Reed has that much of a shot at Top 20 (I'd say WR3/4), but the shot he does have is light years ahead of Robinson and Steele. Worst case scenario is that the deal ends up a push. Reed should at least be a flex play all year. After guys get healthy, both Robinson and Steele are droppable. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Ray_T 716 Posted September 19 33 minutes ago, RedzoneMonster said: I have someone offering me J. Reed for guys I really don’t “need”, but like (D. Robinson and C. Steele). I feel like once both Reed and Love are 100% Reed has a shot to be a top 20 fantasy WR. Apparently the guy offering him doesn’t have the same opinion. Am I wrong here? he has a chance to be top 12. not just top 20. either way, you always make an initial offer thats a bit less than you expect to pay. that's the art of negotiation. he says he doesnt value him that high, but then why is he trying to trade for him? see what I mean? I would not take that offer if I were in your shoes. I dont know that id make a counter offer either. if the offer is (in your opinion) not anywhere close to his true market, there is no point in continuing the negotiation. just say 'no thanks' dont berate him or criticize. just politely say no thanks. if he really wants him he will come back with a legitimate offer. if not, its probably best you are not dealing with the guy anyhow. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
rotisserieking 52 Posted September 20 22 hours ago, RedzoneMonster said: I have someone offering me J. Reed for guys I really don’t “need”, but like (D. Robinson and C. Steele). I feel like once both Reed and Love are 100% Reed has a shot to be a top 20 fantasy WR. Apparently the guy offering him doesn’t have the same opinion. Am I wrong here? As a Reed owner there's now way I'd want those 2 guys to replace his potential. Steele may end up vulturing 3-4 TDs this season but I would not be starting him, and value beyond week 5 is highly questionable. He'll be #4 on the depth chart soon enough and will have ZERO value. DRob is on my bench as a speculative add. With Kupp going down last week I would have expected 7-8 targets but he led the team with 4 for 50 yds on 2 catches. Certainly not encouraging. I'd jump on this one. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
gridiron whirlwinds 9 Posted September 20 (edited) I would take Reed Edited September 20 by gridiron whirlwinds spelling 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
LaChup 212 Posted September 21 Would you trade Reed for Shaheed and Steele in dynasty? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Maximum Overkill 1,308 Posted September 21 52 minutes ago, LaChup said: Would you trade Reed for Shaheed and Steele in dynasty? I'll take Shaheed all day. Christian Watson is Love's guy when he comes back. The Shaheed owner probably wouldn't accept anyhow Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
weepaws 2,986 Posted September 21 3 hours ago, LaChup said: Would you trade Reed for Shaheed and Steele in dynasty? No Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
gridiron whirlwinds 9 Posted September 21 8 hours ago, LaChup said: Would you trade Reed for Shaheed and Steele in dynasty? Nope Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
TBayXXXVII 2,378 Posted September 21 10 hours ago, LaChup said: Would you trade Reed for Shaheed and Steele in dynasty? Basically Reed for Shaheed because Steele has no value in any format. I'd still do that deal... especially on the off chance that Steele actually becomes something. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Skinny_Bastard 157 Posted September 21 On 9/19/2024 at 4:01 PM, RedzoneMonster said: I have someone offering me J. Reed for guys I really don’t “need”, but like (D. Robinson and C. Steele). I feel like once both Reed and Love are 100% Reed has a shot to be a top 20 fantasy WR. Apparently the guy offering him doesn’t have the same opinion. Am I wrong here? Take that deal. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Skinny_Bastard 157 Posted September 21 11 hours ago, LaChup said: Would you trade Reed for Shaheed and Steele in dynasty? No way. Reed is top 10 WR in dynasty. He's eff'n electric. 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
DrG 102 Posted September 21 While the sample size is small, Reed passed the eye test for me. He could emerge as the big play alpha in Green Bay. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Gepetto 1,186 Posted September 21 I agree, Reed is a player you want. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
polecatt 468 Posted September 21 I don't know, I think Reed is the kind of guy I would want to hang onto. His value is most likely going to increase Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Ray_T 716 Posted September 22 7 hours ago, DrG said: While the sample size is small, Reed passed the eye test for me. He could emerge as the big play alpha in Green Bay. agreed. he still needs to develop his game a bit but hes close. At this point I'd say its safe to say he will be a player. what we dont know is exactly how high that ceiling actually is. but in week 1 he was ELECTRIC. The most exciting guy on the field. and as he gains experience, and improves his connection with Love, this will only get better. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
listen2me 23 1,752 Posted September 23 On 9/20/2024 at 11:58 PM, Maximum Overkill said: Christian Watson is Love's guy when he comes back. This isnt true. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Ray_T 716 Posted September 23 3 hours ago, listen2me 23 said: This isnt true. Where's the Love!!!! (pardon the pun.... I couldnt resist) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites