Sheduer or McCarthy

[gcmmidwest]

If you were a coach/Captain starting the season right now who would you pick JJ or sheduer ?

 

[Nomad99]

I would pick retirement....

[gcmmidwest]

25 minutes ago, Nomad99 said:

I would pick retirement....

Lol if you had to pick one 

[polecatt]

It's bad either way but JJ 

[gcmmidwest]

JJ McCarthy ranks at or near the bottom of the league in several key statistical categories for quarterbacks this season, including passer rating ( 65.8), completion percentage (53.7%), and adjusted EPA per play (36th). He is also ranked 33rd in passing Total Points per play among quarterbacks with at least 100 attempts.

 

Passer Rating: 65.8, which is second-worst in the NFL among quarterbacks with at least one start.

 

Completion Percentage: 53.7%, which is dead last in the league among quarterbacks with at least 100 attempts.

 

Adjusted EPA per Play: 36th among quarterbacks with at least 100 dropbacks, ahead of only one other player.

 

Total Points per Play: 33rd among quarterbacks with at least 100 attempts, with a number that rounds to 0 from the nearest hundredth.

 

Turnovers: Has seven turnovers in four games.

[Maximum Overkill]

21 hours ago, gcmmidwest said:

If you were a coach/Captain starting the season right now who would you pick JJ or sheduer ?

 

JJ without a doubt 

One is a first.round pick, the other a 5th. 

[gcmmidwest]

1 hour ago, Maximum Overkill said:

JJ without a doubt 

One is a first.round pick, the other a 5th. 

I'll take sanders 

[LaChup]

The home invaders chose Shadeur in this one.

[weepaws]

6 hours ago, Maximum Overkill said:

JJ without a doubt 

One is a first.round pick, the other a 5th. 

So far, the first pick looks like the 5th rd, can’t commit on the other yet, but, JJ horrible play would be hard to beat, and he has Jefferson. 

[Maximum Overkill]

4 hours ago, weepaws said:

So far, the first pick looks like the 5th rd, can’t commit on the other yet, but, JJ horrible play would be hard to beat, and he has Jefferson. 

I agree, but how could I say Sanders? He can't even get 1st team reps. He's gotta be horrible. I've at least seen JJ look good in flashes. 

For the record, I think both suck. 

[weepaws]

8 hours ago, Maximum Overkill said:

I agree, but how could I say Sanders? He can't even get 1st team reps. He's gotta be horrible. I've at least seen JJ look good in flashes. 

For the record, I think both suck. 

Agreed, I thought JJ has a good future in the nfl, Sanders , I never did.  

[Maximum Overkill]

2 minutes ago, weepaws said:

Agreed, I thought JJ has a good future in the nfl, Sanders , I never did.  

Yup. I really liked JJ coming out. It's still really early but it looks like I'm taking a loss on that one. I drafted him pretty high in a Dynasty Superflex league and already have partial buyers remorse. 

[Ray_T]

On 11/19/2025 at 5:25 AM, Maximum Overkill said:

I agree, but how could I say Sanders? He can't even get 1st team reps. He's gotta be horrible. I've at least seen JJ look good in flashes. 

For the record, I think both suck. 

no guarantee he is horrible as a player.

one of the negatives that caused him to slide was the attitude he took with him into interviews.   if he came off as an entitled (or spoiled) brat, that attitude could have actually been what has kept him off of the field.

Talent wise I feel hes the best QB in Cleveland.    but succeeding at QB requires more than just talent.    it requires committment,  a willingness/desire to learn the right attitude, and an ability to lead others.

and the clown show likely didnt endear him to management.

sometimes the decision not to play someone comes down to the off field stuff.    And I think that especially goes for Sheduer.  

it is far too early to judge if hes got what it takes.    lots of QB have flopped in their first pro game.  John Elway and Peyton Manning are two of those.

its how you bounce back that counts.

so I'd say at this point we need to see if hes got some bounce back in him

 

[LaChup]

I would have a bad attitude too if I sucked. That's why I'm always happy.

[RareN64Dream]

29 minutes ago, LaChup said:

I would have a bad attitude too if I sucked. That's why I'm always happy.

I only suck when I have a shot of Fireball before my NFL games. Jk, I am not in the NFL. But, you seem like you are happy and have good posts on the website.