The Spiller owner in my dynasty league listed below has offered me Spiller and Cotchery for Pierce, Wright, and my #12 rookie pick (it's just a one-round draft). I know Spiller always has the potential to be special and he's said to be fully healthy this year, but I'm a little hesitant here. I get a WR downgrade in both talent and age from Wright to Cotchery AND lose my rookie pick. Plus Pierce is younger than Spiller and could shine in that zone blocking scheme... or can he?
Should I accept or decline? Or try to get a better WR than Cotchery? He has DeAndre Hopkins, Terrance Williams, Reuben Randle, Doug Baldwin, Da'Rick Rodgers, and Randall Cobb as other WRs (and Julio Jones, but doubt he'd deal him).
Thoughts? Thanks!
16-team dynasty; .4 PPR, IDP, 6 pts/passing TDs; start QB, WR, WR, RB, RB, TE, W/T, W/R, K, DEF, D, D, DB, DB, DL, DL
QB: J. Cutler, J. Locker, R. Fitzpatrick
RB: L. McCoy, G. Bernard, B. Pierce, B. Powell, D. Lewis
WR: Mi. Floyd, K. Wright, M. Wheaton, T. Underwood
TE: A. Gates, T. Kelce
K: S. Gostkowski
DEF/ST: Bengals
D: V. Burfict, P. Willis, J. Freeman DB: A. Bethea, T. Gipson DL: C. Wake, Z. Ansah