What were the better picks?

[PanicAttack 13]

OK 2 different leauges: both are not ppr 1 pt per 25pass/10rush/10rec. Had 2 hole in each:

What was better?

Team #1

1.2 LT

2.11 Chester

3.2 Boldin

4.11 Plax

5.2 Shockey

6.11 Delhome

7.2 A. Green

 

Team #2

1.2 SA

2.11 Harrison

3.2 Gates

4.11 Addai

5.2 Hasselbeck

6.11 R. Smith

7.2 Gore

 

I like both but just wondering if the rb/rb/w/w looks better than the rb/w/t/r even though I got great w/t combo

 

What do you think?

Thanks guys

[k9tofive 0]

I think Chester Taylor at 2.11 by your Team 1 was a mistake.

With LT, you should have grabbed a WR and caught him on way back. I am sure an upgrade to Boldin was available. Both Plax/Boldin are WR2s and you need one of them for your WR1. Prefer others at 2.11 like TO, R Moss, Harrison, etc.

 

For Team 2, I think the 3.2 pick of Gates is debateable .

Again, adding a non-RBBC here would have been ideal with SA and Harrison (where you DIDN'T get/take him at 2.11 last time). Instead, Addai is your RB2. Don't get me wrong, he could do well (1100 yds+6TDs) if given 2/3 the touches of Edge - but he is a rookie.

 

Hasselbeck pick is strong - he is the best QB in NFC.

[dalie 2]

I like team 1 better, it seems to have more solid depth all around. Less big ??

[PanicAttack 13]

BUMP---Any others?

[SmilenJack 0]

I am different I like the first roster for the first half of the season and I like roster 2 for the rest,,, I think Addia will become into his own about game 6 or so. But as another poster stated the first roster has more depth. The only problem with it is that if for some reason Manning has a bad game Plex/Shockey may not do crap so you lose in both spots.

 

 

Thanks for posting on mine

[tdubya 0]

I like team #1 better because of depth and of course you have LT. As a previous poster mentioned, it is risky having a WR and TE from the same team. If the Giants passing game is shut down, you will have difficulty making it up at other spots. However, I like the running back depth in team #1 instead of having Addai/Gore as my #2 RB.

 

Thanks for the input on mine.