Not sure I'd trade Rodgers for Manning. i'd hold on him and try get Nelson - in general i am not a huge fan of pairing since a down day for the QB is double the hit but in GB's case thats unlikely - the upside there is way more than the downside - i've lost many a fantasy matchup due to that combo. If you could trade Nelson for Gates that would be a steal - my sense is you may need to give up Thomas for that but if Gates keeps going like he is that may not be a bad deal, although i see him slowing down the next few weeks. See how he does this week.