plummer vs delhomme

[thill 0]

the "geek" rankings had plummer #6 preseason, delhomme #16. i drafted plummer but now have been offered delhomme straight up b/c he has the same buy as the guys other qb--mcnabb.

 

for the rest of the season, you think delhomme can outproduce plummer? i assume the answer may depend on when steve smith comes back. but what do you think?

[RexGrossman 0]

the "geek" rankings had plummer #6 preseason, delhomme #16. i drafted plummer but now have been offered delhomme straight up b/c he has the same buy as the guys other qb--mcnabb.

 

for the rest of the season, you think delhomme can outproduce plummer? i assume the answer may depend on when steve smith comes back. but what do you think?

 

 

Yes. Do the trade!

 

check out my post - SA

[The Hoff 0]

You could probably do better than Plummer on the wire, but I would make the trade. Delhomme will pick it up when Smith comes back, even if not for a few weeks. Then he'll be a top producer. Pick someone else up in the meantime.

[MarkF150 0]

I agree, I would do the trade. Delhomme will be much better when Smith returns and as was stated you can probably pick up another QB for the time being.

[bravo 0]

I would definitely pull the trigger. The Carolina offense runs through Smith, so when he returns you can expect big numbers from Delhomme.

 

I still think Carolina is WAAAAAY overrated as a team, but with Smith Delhomme will definitely outperform Jake the Snake.