HELP! Propsed trade: Give Bledsoe and Desmond Clark, get Hasselback and Ben Troupe

[runninkyle17 0]

Okay, well the title pretty much says it all. But actually I already rejected this trade.

 

So this is what I am thinking.

 

1) I would trade away Bledsoe and Desmond Clark to get Eli Manning and Chirs Baker. What do you guys think?

 

For those of you who didn't catch it here is my team.

 

Alex Smith, Bledsoe, Plummer

Ronnie Brown, Frank Gore, Joseph Addai

D. Driver, Santana Moss, Reggie Brown, T. Williamson

Desmond Clark, Antonio Gates

John Carney

Seahawks, Bills

 

And here is his team:

 

Eli Manning, Grossman, Hasselback

Steven Jackson, DeAngelo Williams, Mike Anderson, Tatum Bell

Joey Galloway, Amani Toomer, Antonio Bryant, Chris Chambers

Chris Baker, Ben Troupe

Carolina Panthers

Nate Kaeding

 

So looking at these teams, what would be some good trades OR do I need to do any trades at all. Remember that Bledsoe is my normal starter and A. Smith is my main backup. Plummer is just there in case he starts to pick it up later in the year. Right now I have the two best TE's and I could use Gates as a bargaining chip since he is not getting much action.

[Melvinbet 5]

Trade seems fair for both of you.

[runninkyle17 0]

Which trade, Eli and Baker for Bledsoe and Clark OR Hasselback and Troupe for Bledsoe and Clark?

[sad sox fan 0]

If he won't go for the QB trade straight up, I'd go with the TE's included...Eli is going to put up good numbers all year long and I personally think he is a better starter in a week in, week out basis. If you can, I'd go after that Carolina D instead of Chris Baker since you'll pretty much be starting Gates the whole season

 

Scratch that, go with Hasselbeck and Troupe over Eli, especially with Branch now in SEA