Opinions needed - should this trade be vetoed?

[dcg 0]

Up to this point the commissioner has approved all trades in our league, but has decided we should vote on this one. I'm leaving my opinions out of this thread, I just want to see what everyone thinks.

 

Westbrook/Droughns/Witten

 

for

 

Addai/Boldin/Stallworth/Gates

 

We start 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 RB/WR, 2 WR, 1 TE, 1 K, 1 DEF

 

Lineups before the trade (12 team league):

 

Team 1

 

Grossman, Culpepper

LT2, Westbrook, McAllister, Droughns, Turner

R. Moss, Colston, R. Smith, Horn

Witten, Daniels

Wilkins, Feely

Dallas, NYG

 

Team 2

 

Brees, Brunell

LJ, Jones-Drew, Morency, Addai

Berrian, Boldin, Evans, Henry, Stallworth

Gates, Baker

Akers, Carney

Redskins, Vikings

 

Please explain your feelings either way. 2 things here - is it ok to vote on some trades and not others at commissioner discretion, and should this trade be allowed.

 

edit - what if team one adds joe horn or rod smith to the trade, so it's 4 for 4?

[dcg 0]

any opinions?

[siorestech 0]

I think Team 1 has the better side. Boldin is a huge upgrade for his WR depth and Stallworth could be huge if he heals up. I think Gates is a big sleeper too and will only get better as Rivers starts throwing more. He can afford to lost teh RB depth especially getting Addai, who is not a bad backup.

 

Team 2 ends up with very little at WR. Henry is not a reliable #3 right now. Westbrook has injury problems too.

 

I'm not sure how you feel about vetoing. Is it unfair? I don't think so. There is an upside and downside for both teams and it's clear they are both trying to improve on their weaknesses.

 

Would you veto to avoid a tough matchup with one of these teams in the future? That's up to you. Team 1 could be a killer in the playoffs.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=243278

[dcg 0]

Edited the OP...what if team one adds Horn or R. Smith to make it a 4 for 4 trade.

[Dakkon79 0]

Let them play, this trade is not that big of a deal. Vetoing a trade like this is kind of silly....

 

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=243329