trade help

[kcjoker 0]

getting offered Ben Roethlisberger and reggie bush for edge james and arnaz battle. seems like i should take it..just wanting some reassurance. leave a link and i'll answer yours.

[kcjoker 0]

anyone, anyone? bueller? bueller?

[budman1 0]

here's the way i see it, the deal comes down to bush for edge, you have mcnabb and are going to play him every week and his bye week is week 9, by then t.green should be back and there playing seattle at home who give up 230 yds passing per game so your not going to start big ben there. so, edge for bush who splits carries and runs back punts? no way imo. good luck. thanks for mine.

[BigDaddy1978 0]

Edge may be in a funk but as a starter he still has more upside than Bush does. Roethlisberger is....for lack of a better word.....worthless right now and why you have Arnaz Battle on your roster to begin with is a headscratcher. Stick with Edge, although I wouldn't start him against Chicago.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=243943

[just_want_2_win 0]

Yes, the other posters are right. At this point Bush isn't as valuable as is Edge, even given Edge's reduced production this year. I think there are better WRs than Battle on WW in most leagues, too.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=243960

[ramblin'wreck 0]

The only case Bush will be more valuable than Edge is in a PPR league. I would take Bush if I get points for reception. He'll continue to get a ton. But in terms of a RB, he's still a work in progress.

 

 

Thanks for helping with mine.

[J5 0]

I would keep James over Bush. James will still get the carries and should see more passes with Leinart in.

[zimbu1234 0]

I agree with ramblin'wreck, if ppr then take the trade...if not, keep edge...good luck...

[itsbigmoni 1]

I'm a frustrated Edge owner also and at point i was so frustrated i offered him straight up for Plaxico. For some strange reason the guy rejected the trade before i had a chance to cancel it. If he has accepted i would've felt stupid. Its hard not to undersell your guys when they frustrate you. I def underselled chambers because just lookng at his name disgusted me ha. But yea, PPR go with bush, if not go with Edge. I think arizona will pick up with Lienhart, he's looked really good. Plus he's a veteran and he's been saying he wants more touches and coaches usualy will at least listen to what veterans say.