K.Jones/D.Carr/C.Frye for J.Jones/M.Vick

[cmac13 0]

Should I trade K. Jones/D.Carr/C.Frye for J. Jones/M.Vick?

 

Start

2 QB

3 RB

3 WR

1 TE

 

Deep 20 man rosters. (i.e. no one on waiver wire)

 

Scoring

QB

1pt- 50 yds passing

1pt- 20 yds rushing

TD- 3 pts

 

RB

1pt- 20 yds rushing

1pt- 20 yds receiving

TD- 5 pts

 

No negitave points.

 

My team:

 

QB Brett Favre

David Carr

Charlie Frye

Joey Harrington

 

RB Ronnie Brown

Kevin Jones

Fred Taylor

Ron Dayne

DeAngelo W

MoJo Drew

Brian Calhoun

 

WR Anquan Boldin

Greg Jennings

Marques Colston

Eddie Kennison

Mark Clayton

 

TE Dallas Clark

Vernon Davis

Eric Johnson

 

We start 2 QBs. My trading partner has only Vick as starting QB (Culpepper and Cutler are other QB)

 

He has

Larry Johnson

Brian Westbrook

Julius Jones

garbage

for RBs

 

I asked for Vick/Westbrook, and he countered with Vick/J. Jones

 

Would you take this trade?

 

I'm thinking that Carr and Frye are both more valuable than Vick in this league, although I'd like to upgrade from Kevin Jones to Julius Jones.

[kcjoker 0]

yeah, i'd do it. Vick has shown he can throw when he needs to, and the jones upgrade would definitely help with the loss of carr, who should only be used when you're other qb's are on byes. how about a little help in return?

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=243959

[just_want_2_win 0]

I agree. Getting Jones is a solid move. Vick will be very adequate at replacing Carr.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=243960

[cmac13 0]

In this scoring system, Frye seems to me to be more valuable than Vick.

 

So is it worth giving up my QB depth (which could be good trade bait in another deal), of both Carr and Frye to upgrade from Kevin to Julius Jones?

 

I'm on the fence.