Trade MJD OR Forte for R. Brown and Calvin Johnson?

[Savior57 0]

I have someone in my league who has Calvin Johnson on the block. If I give him MJD or Forte, I can probably get Calvin and Ronnie Brown without having to give up anything else valuable.

 

league starts 1 QB,2 RB,3 WRs, TE,PK,TM standard scoring with bonuses for 100+yards rushing or receiving or 300+ passing.

NO PPR.

 

My team

 

Aaron Rodgers GNB QB 376.26 5

Carson Palmer CIN QB 47.24 8

Kyle Orton DEN QB 239.18 7

Derrick Ward TAM RB 169.30 8

Jonathan Stewart CAR RB 159.35 4

Le'Ron McClain BAL RB 174.70 7

Matt Forte CHI RB 262.05 5

Maurice Jones-Drew JAC RB 235.30 7

Andre Johnson HOU WR 249.70 10

Hakeem Nicks NYG WR 0.00 10

Muhsin Muhammad CAR WR 126.70 4

Roddy White ATL WR 208.65 4

Santonio Holmes PIT WR 112.10 8

Brent Celek PHI TE 42.40 4

Owen Daniels HOU TE 105.50 10

Mason Crosby GNB K 124.75 5

New York Jets NYJ Defense 190.00 9

 

 

his team

 

Donovan McNabb PHI QB 318.08 4

Matt Hasselbeck SEA QB 75.54 7

Carnell Williams TAM RB 51.60 8

Edgerrin James SEA RB 88.10 7

Fred Jackson BUF RB 112.65 9

Julius Jones SEA RB 100.85 7

Kevin Smith DET RB 184.45 7

Ronnie Brown MIA RB 200.34 6

Antonio Bryant TAM WR 196.45 8

Calvin Johnson DET WR 226.15 7 On

Chad Ochocinco CIN WR 78.00 8

Chaz Schilens OAK WR 34.60 9

Robert Meachem NOR WR 54.90 5

Kellen Winslow TAM TE 63.40 8

Vernon Davis SFO TE 47.90 6

John Carney NOR K 142.25 5

San Diego Chargers SDG Defense 126.00 5

 

Thanks!!!

[whiskey87 0]

i think your stacked now, but i'd try and sell forte first and see if he bites on forte for johnson and ronnie, if not sell mo-jo, RB is always deep, but stud WRs... not so much, go for it

[Savior57 0]

Good stuff, man. Keep 'em comin guys. This could may be the bigger decision I make all year.

[Jambruins 0]

I would keep MJD and Forte. I think they are both going to have huge years and you already have two solid WR with Andre Johnson and White. Holmes, Muhammad or Nicks should be able to get the job done as the WR3.

 

If you do want to trade for Calvin then I would offer Forte first.

[KYSteel 0]

I think I stay put but if you wanted to trade I would go for K. Smith over R. Brown for Forte and a WR3.

[Tyler Jakes 0]

I have someone in my league who has Calvin Johnson on the block. If I give him MJD or Forte, I can probably get Calvin and Ronnie Brown without having to give up anything else valuable.

 

league starts 1 QB,2 RB,3 WRs, TE,PK,TM standard scoring with bonuses for 100+yards rushing or receiving or 300+ passing.

NO PPR.

 

My team

 

Aaron Rodgers GNB QB 376.26 5

Carson Palmer CIN QB 47.24 8

Kyle Orton DEN QB 239.18 7

Derrick Ward TAM RB 169.30 8

Jonathan Stewart CAR RB 159.35 4

Le'Ron McClain BAL RB 174.70 7

Matt Forte CHI RB 262.05 5

Maurice Jones-Drew JAC RB 235.30 7

Andre Johnson HOU WR 249.70 10

Hakeem Nicks NYG WR 0.00 10

Muhsin Muhammad CAR WR 126.70 4

Roddy White ATL WR 208.65 4

Santonio Holmes PIT WR 112.10 8

Brent Celek PHI TE 42.40 4

Owen Daniels HOU TE 105.50 10

Mason Crosby GNB K 124.75 5

New York Jets NYJ Defense 190.00 9

his team

 

Donovan McNabb PHI QB 318.08 4

Matt Hasselbeck SEA QB 75.54 7

Carnell Williams TAM RB 51.60 8

Edgerrin James SEA RB 88.10 7

Fred Jackson BUF RB 112.65 9

Julius Jones SEA RB 100.85 7

Kevin Smith DET RB 184.45 7

Ronnie Brown MIA RB 200.34 6

Antonio Bryant TAM WR 196.45 8

Calvin Johnson DET WR 226.15 7 On

Chad Ochocinco CIN WR 78.00 8

Chaz Schilens OAK WR 34.60 9

Robert Meachem NOR WR 54.90 5

Kellen Winslow TAM TE 63.40 8

Vernon Davis SFO TE 47.90 6

John Carney NOR K 142.25 5

San Diego Chargers SDG Defense 126.00 5

 

Thanks!!!

 

I'd stay pat, or offer up Forte, I'd definitely keep MJD.

 

Thanks for mine!

[Savior57 0]

Forgot to mention that this is a keeper League. The position restricts are according to the starting lineups (1QB 2RB 3 WR ectra) and a previous year keeper restrcition currently has me leaving MJD, Forte, AJ, or Rodgers out in the cold.

[nosferatu9368 0]

I'd stick with what you got MJD and Forte are as good as it gets and you have a pretty good set of receivers.

 

Thanks for answering mine.

 

Good Luck

 

Peace...

[fb4life 0]

Thanks for mine.

 

Your team is stacked compared to his so you have the leverage. I like both MJD and Forte but your WRs would be sick with AJ, Calvin, and R. White. I would offer up Forte as I think MJD is in for a bigger year (as long as he can stay away from the big Smoot hits, sad.) Your RB would still be solid and since you start 3 WR there shouldn't be anyone else in your league to even come close to that trio. If he takes it great, if not you still have a helluva team.