P. Manning or D. McNabb - Who to start week#1

[jmueller44 0]

So Who do YOU start for Week #1?

 

P. Manning Vs JAX

or

D. McNabb @ CAR

 

 

I obviously drafted Manning pretty early, and only grabbed McNabb in the draft because he was still there in Rd 8. There were 2 teams that didn't have their starting QB's yet, and figured, he could be a good Trade option at some point.

 

BUT, now it is week #1 and thinking of starting McNabb over Manning. McNabb's history shows that he puts up big numbers in the seasons first week. Since 2004 he has thrown 3 TDs three years and 2TDs two years on the seasons opening week.

 

So, HELP .... What would you do?

[Cheese Steak 0]

As an Eagles fan I'd like to tell you McNabb but Peyton is the guy to go with today. You're right that you have some QB depth and it may be valuable later on through trades.

 

mine: http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=350056

[garychristian 0]

when it's a coin toss i like the home field

(PEYTON)