Dynasty Deal - Gates & Bush / H.Miller & LT

[Ron_Mexico 0]

I get

Heath Miller

LT

 

I give

Antonio Gates

Reggie Bush

 

 

 

thanks.

[PistolPete2432 0]

Id definately do it if i were you

[Wildman 0]

I get

Heath Miller

LT

 

I give

Antonio Gates

Reggie Bush

thanks.

 

Mostly likely if it's a standard performance league where yardage is valued highly. Scoring rules and roster would help get you better answers.

[g5jamz 0]

Wow.

 

I'd flip a coin. Pluses on either side outweigh the negative of the other. That's probably one of the most balanced situations out there. Where current performance excels...the benefit of the other player negates that effect. Vice versa the other way. As the previous poster mentioned...only impact would be scoring differences, but even then you're talking a very small deviation. That leaves bye-week consideration and strength of schedule. Bush is gonna get his butt kicked in the NFC South and NFC East and the AFC div they play. LT plays the NFC west (easiest NFC division) and the easier AFC division...but do beat themselves up in their own. I'd probably go with the LT/Miller in the short run and it's a pretty sure thing. Bush hasn't proven himself yet.

[Ron_Mexico 0]

Mostly likely if it's a standard performance league where yardage is valued highly. Scoring rules and roster would help get you better answers.

 

WM,

 

Standard Scoring (no PPR)

6 pts per rushing TD

1 pt per every 10 rushing yards.

 

I've got

BUSH

CADDY

WESTBROOK

EDGE

 

start 2 RBs

 

No real need to make this deal,

but a nice upgrade at RB doesn't hurt my depth.

 

The Rivers / Gates combo is still a ??

Heath Miller could be a solid long term TE.

[g5jamz 0]

You've got Bush, Caddy, Westbrook, AND Edge?

 

WTF? You're not serious.

[ALsportsnut 0]

I'd make the trade

And try to trade-off one of your other RBs for a position you may need help at.

[Ron_Mexico 0]

You've got Bush, Caddy, Westbrook, AND Edge?

 

WTF? You're not serious.

 

It's a 12 team dynasty. Entering our 2nd season.

 

We had a rookie draft where the dice

gave me the 2nd pick, I took Caddy.

 

We went in reverse for the main draft,

with 11 and 14 I took Edge and Jamal.

 

I took Droughns in the 11th round,

this off-season I traded Droughns for Westbrook,

and Jamal Lewis for Randy Moss.

 

How did I end up with Bush ?

I finished in last place last year.

 

I'm still baffled as to how I ended up in 12 place.

Gates at TE, Palmer QB.

[wish2win 0]

I get

Heath Miller

LT

 

I give

Antonio Gates

Reggie Bush

thanks.

Oh dear god!!! I hope you've done it already!!!!! Pull that trigger!!!

 

L.T. is a pure stud and he's proven he can perform with an inferior QB. Miller is still a decent TE. Bush is a ??? and Gates is top quality, but you need to do this.

[froggsnflfan53 0]

I wouldnt do it, its a keeper league. Bush has more upside in the long run than LT. Plus gates is probably the #1 target in SD. plus LT takes away alot of goal line chances. Stick with what you got.

 

Thx for opinion on mine.

[semaj33 0]

if this is a dynasty league there is no way i do this deal...yeah reggie bush has never played...but come on in two years you might look back and say, "why did i trade the best tight end and the best running back in the nfl, for LT and the white bubba franks?"

 

you already have enough talent at rb...i wouldn't do it...reggie is 21 years old thats like 12 great years to come...don't pull the trigger...

 

~out