Big time trade...need your help guys...

[jluce32 0]

This guy just proposed a trade to me....

 

He'll give up:

 

Lamont Jordan

David Givens

 

 

I'd have to give up:

 

Chris Chambers

Warrick Dunn

 

 

 

My other WR is Torry Holt, Andre Johnson, and Kennison. It's a strong group and getting Jordan would be huge. I hate giving up Chambers.

 

what do you guys think?

[gobuckeyes 0]

I don't think there is enough difference between Dunn and Jordan to justify giving up Chambers for Givens. Chambers has a lot of upside. Then again, I have tended to think that Jordan is kind of overrated and doubt his numbers will be better than last year (the raiders haven't really looked too good). Dunn just got a lot more valuable since the falcons traded their goal line back. He could get more tds this year.

[jluce32 0]

Yeah, the Ducket trade is HUGE. I think I'm going to stand pat on this. Plus I have Reuben Droughns as my third option at RB...so it's a pretty solid group as is. My first string is Clinton Portis and Dunn. Portis fell to me at the 10 spot b/c people were scared by the injury.

 

 

Thanks.