Trade Help Needed

[jordan5535 0]

i was offered:

 

Rod Smith

Jamal Lewis

 

 

For:

 

Marvin Harrison

 

This is my team....

 

QB D. McNabb

WR M. Harrison

WR D. Mason

WR T. Glenn

RB R. Johnson

RB D. Foster

TE J. Shockey

W/T C. Cooley

W/R D. Rhodes

BN N. Burleson

BN K. Warner

BN M. Brunell

BN C. Perry

BN R. Ferguson

BN H. Baskett

BN J. Norwood

[paul revere 0]

I don't think I would do it. Harrison is going to be even better this year with the departure of Edge. Rod Smith is good...not great. Jamal Lewis has to prove he's the same RB from 2 years ago.

[Snoopy 0]

I would not do this. You trade 1 stud for 2 "serviceables". I would try to find a better RB on his roster and try to trade straight up for that guy.

 

Please take a stab at mine: http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=225836

[kbtegp 0]

I dont take that trade. You lose across the board.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=225825

[jwmatthews3 0]

I have mixed feelings. Rod Smith is a nullity in this trade, so it comes down to whether Jamal Lewis has a chance to return to stud status. You do need another runningback, but you could also use Marvin Harrison.

 

My gut tells me Marvin will fall off a bit this year, and Jamal may thrive with McNair at QB. Though Marvin went about #19 in my draft, and Jamal went #38, I'm thinking maybe do it.

[smr292 0]

no way.

 

Please see mine:

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=225934