Kitna or Brooks

[J5 0]

I sat Culpepper, which was a good idea. Who should I start Kitna or Brooks?

[lionsfan8138 0]

If I were you, I'd play Kitna. The Lions will undoubtedly play from behind and pass more, and while Trufant may shut down Williams, Corey Bradford may get open often. I also think that Martz will wanna throw out of the backfield to Jones. Brooks is way too unpredictable, and if Moss doesn't play well, Brooks' stats may be horrible.

 

Please respond to mine: http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=230197

[MattJonesRepresent 0]

I would play Kitna, although Moss and Brooks is very enticing...go team Kitna!

 

Thanks fro mine!

[Trey5 0]

I guess Kitna - he will probably protect the ball better. Although if your league doesn't deduct for INT's then I'd go Brooks

[J5 0]

It is only -1 for int's. I am thinking about going Brooks. He has the better weapons and plays against a worse secondary on Monday night.

[Dan Hawkins 0]

Kitna. Better offense and he has Roy Williams to throw to.

[smedia 0]

Tough choice I have a decision that is close to yours but I like Kitna and Williams but like Brooks and his targets better Moss and Jordan who was the second leading reciever on the Raiders

 

Brooks

 

Please answer mine

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=230212

[Emteesee 4]

I'd go with Kitna because I've owned Brooks a couple of years in the past and have just never been a big fan of the guy. I don't think the Raiders are going to do too well this year.

 

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=230215

[mambokings 0]

Until I see Aaron Brooks throw more often to HIS team than he does the opposition, I'd certainly go with Jon Kitna. Kitna did a solid job in Cinci when he was asked to play and does have some decent weapons at his disposal in Detroit. It's great that your league only deducts -1 for INTs...that will really help as a Brooks owner. I just haven't seen any indication yet that Brooks is going to be any better in Oakland than he was in New Orleans. I've read that the Raiders staff have been frustrated with what they've seen (and who could blame them). It's a toss up this week, but Kitna - in Mike Martz offense and most likely playing from behind - seems like he's got higher potential.

[bobpate17 0]

I like brooks. I would go with him. I mean I like him better than kitana.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=230242

[nprice1776 0]

I would go with kitna