Manning for Manning Trade?

[kmcgator 0]

Giving Up: E. manning, L. Jordan, R. Wayne, K. Winslow

 

Getting: P. Manning, R. Droughns (or D. Foster), M. Muhammad, A. Gates

 

What do you think? I am currently 2-1 and like my roster but always looking for upgrades!

 

Give me your thoughts and I will gladly help you in return!

 

My roster:

 

QB's: E. Manning, C. Frye

RB's: R. Johnson, S. Jackson, L. Jordan

WR's: S. Smith, P. Burress, R. Wayne, M. Jones

TE: K. Winslow, C. Cooley

D: Dallas

K: Stover, Vanderjagt

 

kmcgator

[Dascoopman 0]

If I were you i'd stay put, Eli is putting up good numbers and the Giants look like they are passing a lot giving him a lot of opportunities, and i'd rather have Winslow and Wayne than Gates and Muhammad, honestly right now Gates is not looking good, I have him as well and it sucks. I'd stay put if I were you think your losing more than your gaining just for Peyton. Thanks for mine.

[bobpate17 0]

don't do it. gates is not going to put good numbers as his qb doesn't throw much. ppl are trying to sell him while he is not all the way down. I say stick with what u have.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=238438

[seh2000 5]

don't do it. gates is not going to put good numbers as his qb doesn't throw much. ppl are trying to sell him while he is not all the way down. I say stick with what u have.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=238438

I agree, stay put. Usual multi-player for M/p is a mess. thanks for mine: seh2000.

[EZ Money 0]

Don't do this. Eli should continue to put up big numbers. The Giants have no defense so he'll be forced to throw all year. When all's said and done I think he and Peyton will have similar stats so you're not gaining that much, if anything.

 

Please see mine...

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=238463