Am I giving up too much on this trade?

[Football Fan 20 2]

I will be trading Jones-Drew and Colston for Steve Smith. I know I give up a lot but WRs are kinda weak. Tell me what you think

 

Dynasty League 1pt=10yds rush/receive 1pt=50yds pass 1pt=75yds return 6pts=rush/receive/return TD 4pts=pass td NO PPR Start 1QB 2RB 3WR 1TE 1K 1DEF

 

 

My team

 

QB

Rivers

Roethlisberger

 

RB

LT

Jacobs

Jones-Drew

McGahee

Marshawn Lynce

 

WR

Chad Johnson

Colston

Deion Branch

Mark Clayon

 

TE

Heath Miller

 

K

Gostowski

 

DEF

Green Bay

Denver

[mec411 0]

I will be trading Jones-Drew and Colston for Steve Smith. I know I give up a lot but WRs are kinda weak. Tell me what you think

 

Dynasty League 1pt=10yds rush/receive 1pt=50yds pass 1pt=75yds return 6pts=rush/receive/return TD 4pts=pass td NO PPR Start 1QB 2RB 3WR 1TE 1K 1DEF

My team

 

QB

Rivers

Roethlisberger

 

RB

LT

Jacobs

Jones-Drew

McGahee

Marshawn Lynce

 

WR

Chad Johnson

Colston

Deion Branch

Mark Clayon

 

TE

Heath Miller

 

K

Gostowski

 

DEF

Green Bay

Denver

 

You have a lot of depth at RB and you have a strong WR corp already. I would still make the move, here's why. Last year, and much to my chagrin, LT was as productive as the number 9 and 10 RB's COMBINED. He will make up for the loss of MJD, whose stock is down in a non-PPR league. If this were a PPR league, I wouild say no, stay put. But you're getting a number 1 WR in return to go with another number 1 WR. Yeah you give up a bonafied number 1 RB but you have LT, Lynch, Magahee, Jacobs. I am surprised you have yet to make this trade, to be honest. I just think you need to run comparisons and make sure what I am telling you is right. I wouldnt want to steer you wrong, but I think I would make the trade. Good Luck.

[nosferatu9368 0]

I'm not sure i'd make this trade, Colston has a better Offense around him and could put up nearly the same numbers as Smith, if the other team you are trading with needs Jones-Drew offer him Jones-Drew and Branch. I just think you're giving up to much.

 

Good Luck

 

Peace...

[scoob13us 0]

Delhome isn't the best QB in the league but he does target Steve Smith alot....I would hold off on the trade b/c U have WR depth.....

[ir0nchef 0]

I think its too much.

 

Even though you're so deep at RB, that you probably wont even use MJD...I would not want to give up Colston.

 

In some instances, MJD could net Steve Smith straight up. If that doesn't work, throwing in Clayton should be enough. MJD and Branch is as high as I'd go.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=283337

[Poloc2289 0]

Yea, I think you're giving up too much. I know you have great depth at RB but I think Colston will actually outproduce Steve Smith this year. Colston is in a much better situation and of course doesn't have Jake Delhomme passing to him. Best of luck to ya

[lancej22 0]

I would wait until after wk 1, then re-eval the trade...check my post, thanks!

[ullloveit 0]

your giving uo too much. With your rb depth you should be able to get a nice wr in return without trading colston.

 

Mine please

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=283387

[beatsdesign 0]

Way too much imo....delhomme is on his way down and the saints are on their way up....oh yeah they also dont have horn....chad and colston is just a sick combo as having smith....

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...=0#entry3256199