Riddle me this FF guys.. trade evaluation

[B Gruden 0]

I proposed this trade to a good guy in my league

His Ronnie Brown went down and he has no RBs worth mentioning

I have offered B Jacobs, T Jones and D Driver

Essentially giving him 2 starting RBs and a # 1 WR

For.. Addai. K Keith in case Addai goes down and L Fitzgerald

Some in my league are objecting

My Other RBs are LJ, Westy and Bob Marley err I mean Travis Henry

I think this is a fair trade

Comments please

Thanks in advance

[WindyCitySportsFan 0]

I proposed this trade to a good guy in my league

His Ronnie Brown went down and he has no RBs worth mentioning

I have offered B Jacobs, T Jones and D Driver

Essentially giving him 2 starting RBs and a # 1 WR

For.. Addai. K Keith in case Addai goes down and L Fitzgerald

Some in my league are objecting

My Other RBs are LJ, Westy and Bob Marley err I mean Travis Henry

I think this is a fair trade

Comments please

Thanks in advance

 

 

They are objecting to you being stacked at RB. I'm not even sure how you decide who would play each week at the #2 spot. It would appear it's somewhat stacked in your favor. If he's desperate though, that's not your fault.

 

Please see mine.

[gram 0]

i agree w the previous. you are throwing him chump change. yeah it may seem like a lot to him cause brown is gone but in the you will have 3 of the potential top 5 rbs..thats just not right...but hey the guys needs it...ieschhh

 

mine please

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=297735

[B Gruden 0]

i agree w the previous. you are throwing him chump change. yeah it may seem like a lot to him cause brown is gone but in the you will have 3 of the potential top 5 rbs..thats just not right...but hey the guys needs it...ieschhh

 

mine please

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=297735

[just_want_2_win 0]

I proposed this trade to a good guy in my league

His Ronnie Brown went down and he has no RBs worth mentioning

I have offered B Jacobs, T Jones and D Driver

Essentially giving him 2 starting RBs and a # 1 WR

For.. Addai. K Keith in case Addai goes down and L Fitzgerald

Some in my league are objecting

My Other RBs are LJ, Westy and Bob Marley err I mean Travis Henry

I think this is a fair trade

Comments please

Thanks in advance

 

On the surface, maybe not so fair but I think analysis shows it to be maybe tilted toward you but not objectionable.

 

Jacobs is finally healthy and heating up. The RBBC in NY is fading for now.

Jones might benefit from the QB change in NY but he has upcoming games vs. PIT and DAL but then gets MIA

Driver is always a top WR but is fading some right now.

 

Addai...is Addai. So so schedule, KK situation I don't think is so clear cut that he will def. take snaps or after yesterday def. won't take snaps any given week.

KK is just a handcuff more or less.

Fitz has a crazy QB situation and Boldin can be the fave of whoever's in at QB at any time, pushing Fitz' numbers down some.

 

So I don't think it's outrageously stacked in your favor to the point it should be vetoed down. Just others don't want you to have Addai.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=298996

[nosferatu9368 0]

I wouldn't like the trade either if I was in your league, not sure i'd veto it but I wouldnt like it. I think if you left out Fitz for Driver it would be more fair. I really dont think much of Thomas Jones and hes on my team "ick"

 

The problem most would have is your getting the clear cut best player in the trade and only giving up back-ups, then your getting the better WR too. Leave out the WR's as I said and it becomes a little more fair...

 

Good luck

 

Please see mine

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=298974

 

Peace...