Trade Advice

[kac1 0]

I Get:

Ben Roethlisberger

Marvin Harrison

Laurence Maroney

 

I Give:

Philip Rivers

Joseph Addai

Dwayne Bowe

 

Do I make this trade? I really do not want to give up Addai. PPR league with some of the scoring listed below..

Completions (1)

Passing Yards (20 yards per point; 3 points at 300 yards; 5 points at 400 yards)

Passing Touchdowns (6)

Interceptions (-1)

Rushing Yards (10 yards per point; 3 points at 150 yards; 5 points at 200 yards; 10 points at 250 yards)

Rushing Touchdowns (6)

Receptions (1)

Reception Yards (15 yards per point; 2 points at 100 yards; 4 points at 150 yards; 6 points at 200 yards)

Reception Touchdowns (6)

 

The rest of my roster is as follows..

QB: (we start 2) Rivers, McNabb, Warner

RB: Addai, Bush, M.Barber, B.Jacobs, Grant, J.Jones

WR: Bowe, Fitz, TO, Holmes

TE: Witten, Davis

K: Folk

DEF: (we start 2) Arizona, Minnesota, Tennessee

[kac1 0]

I declined this trade and he countered with

 

I get:

Ben Roethlisberger

Marvin Harrison

Laurence Maroney

 

 

I give:

Philip Rivers

Marion Barber

Dwayne Bowe

 

Do I accept?

[ff07 2]

I absolutely would NOT do that trade. Big Ben - Rivers is sort of a wash (I actually like Rivers better the rest of the season), Harrison - Bowe is maybe a slight upgrade (all depends on his health), but Maroney - Addai is a huge downgrade. If I were going to do this, I'd check what else he had at the WR position.

 

thanks for mine

[Eaglephan 0]

Glad you declined the first offer.

 

I think Ben > Rivers

Barber and Maroney are close, but Maroney is on a high powered offense, but injury concerns

Harrison > Bowe. Yes, Harrison is hurt, but I think he'll be a 2nd half stud.

 

Do it.

[spydergs1 0]

With the Marion Barber instead of Addia I would probably do the trade. I think you will come out on top with Harrison cause the other two are probably a wash.

[Kingpin 0]

I think it is an upgrade with the obvious risk on Marvin's health. If he is OK, then it is an upgrade for you.

[sta 5]

Since you took Addai out I would do it.

 

Thanks for mine

[warwar123 0]

I'd do the new one getting Maroney.

[doriantodd 0]

I think Ben is better than Rivers too. I'd do the new one giving up Barber.

[hotfootteddy 0]

With your second option of Barber rather than Addai, I'd take the trade.

[tbone2370 0]

I would do it with Barber...no way do you move Addai