Need quick answer on trade offered to me

[T Man 0]

I was offered LT and Garrard for Bush and McNabb in my league.

 

We start 2 QBs and I have Adrian Peterson already but LT is hard to reject.

 

Would you make this deal?

 

I have Palmer and JTO as my other QBs.

 

Leave a link I will answer yours.

[bwings 0]

If its a ppr league, I'd say a definite no. LT's health status would probably scare me away from doing it even if its not.

[panthro 0]

Again, without scoring rules it's hard to say. If you get points for special teams yards (P/K returns) then I'd say resoundingly "no". Even still, I think McNabb is a better QB this year than Garrard, and Bush is a better back this year (so far) than L.T. Unless you think that the Chargers are really going to turn it around this season and L.T. is going to explode, and that McNabb's Eagles are going to continue to slide into mediocrity. I can see the argument, because both are possible, but it's a big risk.

 

So, I think overall, I'd say no.

 

Here's mine: http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=328211

 

Thanks in advance, and good luck!

[jared7683 0]

If you have Bush and it is a PPR league, keep him...my league is PPR and he is blowing away all other RBs...if it is standard scoring, I would lean more towards LT

 

see mine

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=328216