HELP with Trade Offer!

[katfile 0]

We have 12 team performance league scoring with pass TD count for 6 points. Here is my roster... I need help since McNabb went down and I got a proposal from another team.

 

His Offer: I get (Phillip Rivers & Mike Bell) and he gets (Julius Jones & Ryan Grant)

 

MY ROSTER:

 

QB Byron Leftwich

RB DeAngelo Williams

RB Frank Gore

WR Randy Moss

WR Roddy White

WR/TE Bernard Berrian

D/ST Packers D/ST

K Robbie Gould

Bench Pierre Thomas

Bench Ryan Grant

Bench Eddie Royal

Bench Matt Schaub

Bench Julius Jones

Bench Patrick Crayton

Bench Bears D/ST

Bench Donovan McNabb

 

HIS ROSTER:

 

QB Matt Hasselbeck, Sea QB

RB Maurice Jones-Drew, Jac RB

RB Mike Bell, NO RB

WR Steve Smith, Car WR

WR T.J. Houshmandzadeh, Sea WR P

WR/TE Justin Gage, Ten WR

D/ST Giants D/ST, NYG D/ST

K Ryan Longwell, Min K

Bench Philip Rivers, SD QB

Bench LeSean McCoy, Phi RB

Bench Santana Moss, Was WR

Bench Felix Jones, Dal RB P

Bench Jeremy Shockey, NO TE P

Bench Kevin Boss, NYG TE

Bench Bo Scaife, Ten TE Q

Bench Chris Wells, Ari RB

[garychristian 0]

you'd be taking it in the a$$ in this trade...!!! rb's way more important & bell will be worthless before long...mc nabb will get better before long & leftwich will fill in nicely...keep your rb's it's gonna be a long season & you'll need them

 

see mine please

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=350544

[smartgenius 0]

Hmmmm...I kind of disagree. To me you want a strong starting lineup first, strong bench second. I might ask for a different RB--I like Felix Jones or Chris Wells better than Bell--but Rivers is a huge upgrade over Leftwich, who I would not count on to be consistently good. Also remember that Rivers went off after LT got hurt (which he is again) and will have a great pass catching back filling in in Sproles. I say do it, but with Wells or Felix J.

 

Please see mine:

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...p;#entry4050495

[fatneck13 0]

I don't make this trade. I still think Schaub could blow up this year & McNabb should be back. Ryant Grant and Julius Jones are solid primary backs IMO and while Bell may have a good year i am still leery of him with Thomas and Bush in the mix.

 

I agree that Rivers is a big upgrade over Wrongwich but I think you are still giving up too much.

 

Mine: http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=350553

[katfile 0]

Thanks guys for all your input... I agree with a couple of you and i think it maybe a little too early to make a desparate move in order to upgrade at QB... if I had to give up one of RB, I'd do it but 2 is little too much at this time....

Now if it was later and I still suck at QB.. i will probably make this move, considering its past bye weeks and i dont see anything from leftwich and/or McNabb doesnt come back healthy n productive. Thanks again!