2017 1.06 pick for 2018 1st round pick + Meredith - comment please

[gilbertfl6 0]

Got another trade that I might offer up but before I do wanted to run it by the group

 

Guy in my league in rebuild mode he finished last place last year so unless he hits home runs with his rookies he will probably be near the bottom again but he has been accumulating first round picks. I'm new in the league so I did not see what and who he traded but he has no real offense talent so either he started with nothing or traded it away to accumulate the firsts - he has the 1.01 1.04, and 1.08.

 

Here is what I am considering but not sure he will bite. I give my 2017 1.06 for his 2018 1st round + Cameron Meredith. I think it is a no brainer and I would not take it if I were him but he might have rookie fever....

 

I'm new to dynasty so thought I'd run it by you all.

It is dynasty PPR, 12 teams, roster 54, Start QB 1 / RB 1-3 / WR 2-5 / TE 1-4 / PK 1 for 9 total offense + 9 defense

My roster (primary offense players)

QB: Tyrod, Bradford, Bridgewater, Alex Smith

RB: Devonta Freeman, Doug Martin, Jalen Richard, Prosise, Jacquizz Rodgers

WR: Julio Jones, Willie Snead, Kelvin Benjamin, Decker, Moncrief, Eli Rogers, Perriman, Doctson

TE: Gronk, Hooper, Swoope, Richard Rodger

Picks: 1.06, 3.06, 5.06, 6.06

 

Just traded my 2.06 for Doctson with someone else in my league which I believe was a good deal. From everything I read in the various sites the odds of rookie picks panning out are a bit of a crapshoot and better off to trade uncertain picks for players with names and some history. Especially for picks oustide of the first 6-8 picks???

 

In the case of the 1.06 for the 2018 1st + Meredith I believe I would just be getting Meredith for free though a little delayed gratification on the first rounder. And if he is as bad this year as he was last I will be getting a 1.01 - if not a 1.91 odds are probably better than the 1.06 I'm putting on the table

 

Thoughts and comments please...

 

[Ray_T 753]

Got another trade that I might offer up but before I do wanted to run it by the group

 

Guy in my league in rebuild mode he finished last place last year so unless he hits home runs with his rookies he will probably be near the bottom again but he has been accumulating first round picks. I'm new in the league so I did not see what and who he traded but he has no real offense talent so either he started with nothing or traded it away to accumulate the firsts - he has the 1.01 1.04, and 1.08.

 

Here is what I am considering but not sure he will bite. I give my 2017 1.06 for his 2018 1st round + Cameron Meredith. I think it is a no brainer and I would not take it if I were him but he might have rookie fever....

 

I'm new to dynasty so thought I'd run it by you all.

It is dynasty PPR, 12 teams, roster 54, Start QB 1 / RB 1-3 / WR 2-5 / TE 1-4 / PK 1 for 9 total offense + 9 defense

My roster (primary offense players)

QB: Tyrod, Bradford, Bridgewater, Alex Smith

RB: Devonta Freeman, Doug Martin, Jalen Richard, Prosise, Jacquizz Rodgers

WR: Julio Jones, Willie Snead, Kelvin Benjamin, Decker, Moncrief, Eli Rogers, Perriman, Doctson

TE: Gronk, Hooper, Swoope, Richard Rodger

Picks: 1.06, 3.06, 5.06, 6.06

 

Just traded my 2.06 for Doctson with someone else in my league which I believe was a good deal. From everything I read in the various sites the odds of rookie picks panning out are a bit of a crapshoot and better off to trade uncertain picks for players with names and some history. Especially for picks oustide of the first 6-8 picks???

 

In the case of the 1.06 for the 2018 1st + Meredith I believe I would just be getting Meredith for free though a little delayed gratification on the first rounder. And if he is as bad this year as he was last I will be getting a 1.01 - if not a 1.91 odds are probably better than the 1.06 I'm putting on the table

 

Thoughts and comments please...

 

it might help if we saw what his team looked like.

 

going on the assumption that his team will be bad, I cant see how this would be a bad deal for you.

 

But

 

If I were him, I wouldnt consider this deal either. If it's a 2-3 year rebuild where you are drafting top 3, then those draft picks are fantasy gold and you dont trade them for anything.

 

Either way, you can make the offer, but if his team is as weak as you say and he has a brain in his head, he should shut it down quickly.