Eli manning @ SEA or Kurt Warner Vs. STL

[BIGPLAYER06 0]

will eli put up better numbers than kurt this week.

 

for soem reason i always feel more comfortable starting kurt warner than eli. I think its because i dont feel eli is very consistant. is he going to be good week in/week out or is he going to let me down?

 

who would u start--> Kurt vs. STL or Eli @SEA

 

leave link

[Big4Jerm3 0]

Eli!!! Everyone told me that I should star Pennington over him last weekend and we all know how that turned out. Ride Eli out this season. Afterall, he does have good DNA

 

 

My link Helpppp HELLLLLLLLLLPPPPPPPPPPP

[Integral 0]

Eli!!! Everyone told me that I should star Pennington over him last weekend and we all know how that turned out. Ride Eli out this season. Afterall, he does have good DNA

My link Helpppp HELLLLLLLLLLPPPPPPPPPPP

 

Id go with Eli, because it will be a shootout I think. Seattle will get their run/pass going and NYG will be passing a lot. But it is a tough one my friend. Warner is a safe bet to put up 225 and a TD though. Thanks for your reply to mine!

[Bearshopeful 0]

Comming off the win last week The Giants are stoked and will be looking for some revenge against seattle for last season. Eli is looking better each week (against 2 great teams) I would take the risk and go with Eli. Even if Warner DOES out perform, I still think Eli will put up good numbers that you won't loose any sleep over.

[Bigunreal1 0]

Eli - I think he threw for 344 yards against Seattle last season.

[olemissrebel 0]

ELI will throw at least two TD's. I would go with him over Warner.

[Ray_T 753]

I'd start Warner.

 

hes got better receivers, and is skilled enough to use them. Edges presence also helps warners game a lot. If you could put Eli Manning in Warners spot, he may be able to get as many passing yards as his brother.

 

however, that being said... Eli has Plaxico Burress and Amani Toomer instead of Fitzgerald and Boldin.

 

Eli is also facing a fairly decent Seattle Defense.

 

Warner gets to face St Louis Defense.

 

I'd play warner this week.

[Pound 0]

I'd start Warner over Eli.

 

I'm starting him this week, but I don't have much choice. Lets get another 300 3td game!

[Melvinbet 5]

The Giants have a much better o-line than ARI. They will have a better result. BUT, Warner should do well against the Rams. Time to show up the old team.

 

I don't think you can go wrong with either.