QB Bulger or Vick...have to trade one

[Springfield Isotopes 0]

Ok standard scoring...

 

I have Vick and Bulger(#3 & #4 in my league respectively)

RB's: LT, LJordan, Addai(can start 3... 1 RB/WR Flex)

WR's: Boldin, CJ, Driver, R Williams(Jac),

TE: Watson and McMichael

 

I offered the following

 

Vick for Gore and Lundy

 

He rejected and said Bulger might be an option for him

 

Do I do this?

 

I am 4-4 in 6th place in a 10 team league

 

Thanks

[Jonny_P 0]

Ok standard scoring...

 

I have Vick and Bulger(#3 & #4 in my league respectively)

RB's: LT, LJordan, Addai(can start 3... 1 RB/WR Flex)

WR's: Boldin, CJ, Driver, R Williams(Jac),

TE: Watson and McMichael

 

I offered the following

 

Vick for Gore and Lundy

 

He rejected and said Bulger might be an option for him

 

Do I do this?

 

I am 4-4 in 6th place in a 10 team league

 

Thanks

 

Frankly, both Vick and Bulger are about even fantasy-wise, imo. Give whichever you can get the most for to improve the rest of your team.

[NotAClue 0]

Thanks for your reply. Vick just keeps getting better and Atlanta has a very favorable schedule from here on out. I say him wanting Bulger is actually a boon for you.

[bunnerjk 0]

I would rather keep Bulger but if you trade him I would want someone better than Gore and Lundy in return.

[rdub15 0]

it's a decent pickup for you...Bulger is consistent as they come but you need a decent starter behing LT and Jordan isn't cutting it. Gore is solid and Lundy could be a good flex player w/ Addai. Vick could fall off towards the end of the season but right now he's racking up those points so i say go for it.

[surfnturf3g01 0]

I agree with bunnerjk...exactly

[ramblin'wreck 0]

I would prefer consistency of Bulger over Vick's explosiveness... Trade Vick! I also think you can get someone better than Gore in return..

 

Thanks for mine..

[markaj06 0]

im not sold on vick yet, id say trade vick for a sold rb

[Cjt727 0]

Bulger's been doing good all season long, but Vick has just suddenly emerged too. And both of them have pretty even schedules for the rest of the year too. This is a tough one, but I think I'm going to say keep Bulger just because of Vick's unconsistancy in the earlier part of the year.

 

Good luck with that.

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=250314

[just_want_2_win 0]

Vick has been super lately but he can as easily give you 3 pts. as 30 pts. I say stick with Bulger, who's consistent, and use Vick's big performances to net yourself a great RB.

 

http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=250322