TX Steel 0 Posted November 2, 2007 10 team league, standard scoring, no PPR. Note how many starters we have, so this trade involves players who will start every week: My roster--starters in bold: QB1: Brees QB2: McNabb RB1: Addai RB2: Maroney RB/WR: Lynch WR1: Fitz WR2: B Edwards WR3: W Welker TE: Gonzo OP1: Favre OP2: K Watson OP3: L Evans BENCH: J Chatman (bye), C Henry (CIN), K Clemens His roster: QB1: Big Ben QB2: J Campbell RB1: LT RB2: C Henry RB/WR: A Green WR1: S Moss WR2: Cotchery WR3: CJ TE: D Clark OP1: C Cooley OP2: B Marshall OP3: K Jones BENCH: Plax (bye), B Jacobs (bye), J Feely (bye) I offered him Addai and any one of my QBs for LT. He replied via email and said that LT's been giving him points but not what he expected. That tells me he'd be willing to trade him. He goes on to ask "would you get one of my QBs?" Now, if I could swap Addai and Brees/McNabb/Favre for LT and Big Ben/Campbell that would make it even better. I was willing to get only LT. I don't know if he'd do a 2-for-2 swap for sure though. Let's say worst case for me is I give up Addai & Brees for LT. Is that worth it? Best case is I get Big Ben or Campbell as well. The main reason I want to trade Addai is because of his splits with Keith and come playoff time. Dungy normally sits his starters the last game or two and I don't want a big empty spot on my roster. Do you think LT will play thru week 17? Thanks, and leave a link so I can return the favor... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Dabears33 0 Posted November 2, 2007 I would do it. If he is willing to give up Campbell, I would take him too. I don't see him moving Rothlesberger. Turner finally realized that he needs to give LT the ball more. Brees/Addai for LT is fair. Thanks for answering mine. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
rottytiny 7 Posted November 2, 2007 I'd do it. Withor without Campbell, try it with Campbell first if he turns it down go for ti without him. Did he want to send you a QB too? Ask him before you offer the trade and see what kind of reply you get. You stil have 2 good Qbs and Chatman is a starting Rb to fil in your open spot, do it. LT will have to play all season while your right, Addai may get rested before the palyoffs if the Colts have a 1 or 2 seed sewn up. http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=299793 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
bobby332 0 Posted November 2, 2007 I would go for the Brees/Addai for LT/Rothlisberger. When you think about it, Addai for LT isn't overly weighed in favor of LT, so Brees for Rothlisberger is also fair, Brees being slightly better. I think the trade would be more in his favor if he only gave you Campbell...that guy stinks in comparison to Brees. http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=299779 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BG711 0 Posted November 2, 2007 I'd make the trade without Big Ben or Campbell (if you can get one it will be a bonus). I like LT for the rest of the year and am concerned about Addai being rested down the stretch as you stated. Thanks for mine. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
k2208 0 Posted November 2, 2007 I think I would do it also w/ or w/out a QB. With a QB is just a bonus. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites