Rate this trade: LJ, Galloway and Bears for Young, Driver and Colts

[jdibella 0]

My team:

 

McNabb, Delhomme

Portis, T. Jones, Felix Jones, Selvin Young, Ray Rice

Owens, Burress, Driver, V. Jackson, D. Mason

Sheffler

Colts DST

N. Rackers

 

I get:

 

Larry Johnson, Joey Galloway and Bears DST

 

He gets:

 

Selvin Young, Donald Driver and Colts DST

 

Who's getting the better deal? (Post link.)

[jdibella 0]

Wow, not one reply.

[j0ker 3]

This isn't as easy as it looks. Even though Selvin young is in the shanahan fantasy hell he is doing about as well as LJ which is unbelievable..KC is just terrible so it's almost a wash at this point but you have to have hope that LJ will turn it around so I think your getting the better deal. I like Driver over Galloway so he is getting the better deal. The Bears are an upgrade over the Colts even though Hester is out for now..but the Colts lost Sanders also. I would do this trade

[jdibella 0]

This isn't as easy as it looks. Even though Selvin young is in the shanahan fantasy hell he is doing about as well as LJ which is unbelievable..KC is just terrible so it's almost a wash at this point but you have to have hope that LJ will turn it around so I think your getting the better deal. I like Driver over Galloway so he is getting the better deal. The Bears are an upgrade over the Colts even though Hester is out for now..but the Colts lost Sanders also. I would do this trade

 

You really like Driver over Galloway? I was thinking Galloway (when healthy) is a better option.

[j0ker 3]

With Rodgers firing on all cylinders I see Driver being the better option, but granted Galloway is decent when healthy. I just think the Green bay offense is more pass happy as TB is run first team. Go with your gut though

[cdogge 17]

You really like Driver over Galloway? I was thinking Galloway (when healthy) is a better option.

 

WHEN healthy...not to mention the QB situation in TB....

 

I would do the trade....the bears defense is nasty right now....

[bblank1975 0]

Thanks for your input on mine.

 

I think this is a decent trade and that you are getting the better end of the deal. Driver is good, but Jennings is getting pretty much everything right now, except for 1 td from Driver.

 

Galloway is the best wr in Tampa. LJ has more opportunity than Selvin does and the bears D is probably the best now that merriman is out in SD.

[trich20 0]

It seems pretty even across the board... I think I'd rather have Galloway/LJ package though

[Wallyworld 0]

I'd go for it, thanks for answering mine.

[patmusk911 0]

i would do the deal considering the sanders injury and selvin young not being a reliable start ever...

 

but after you acquire LJ, trade him immediately after a good week.

[sameolpete 0]

Thanks for answering mine. The way i see it with Galloway possibly being injured and him getting up their in age right not i would say Driver is a better WR. LJ just plain old is not the same and KC is horrible. The Chicago D is still one of the best and the Colts D is not what it used to be especially without Sanders. Selvin Young plays in a bad RBBC but if one of those backs goes down you can really see his workload increase. In the end alot of all this just comes down to luck.

[jdibella 0]

i would do the deal considering the sanders injury and selvin young not being a reliable start ever...

 

but after you acquire LJ, trade him immediately after a good week.

 

This is what I'm thinking. There are some teams that are struggling at RB so I'll probably deal him at the first opportunity I can get.

[jsw0002 0]

Theres not much to say that hasnt been said but I'd go with the trade. Mostly for the upgrade at Defense.

[Nanda 0]

I think it's pretty much a push except for the defenses. And you win there. Go for it.