JagFan

Not sure I’d give them much of a chance fully healthy. Maybe if they had Dionte Johnson…

You really can’t blame Darnold. He’s the fourth 1st round QB the Jets have ruined in the 2000’s. Let’s all be thankful they helped cry baby, look at me Rodgers flame out his career this year.

I’m sure I don’t have to go into a long tirade about how bad coaching ruins good QB prospects. Or how the right situation / coaching staff can correct that. Mayfield comes to mind…. Trevor has flashed the talent, and I wouldn’t throw the baby out with the bath water just yet.

Monty is getting that ring this year.

This does make sense. And if Montgomery is gone, I’d expect them to bring in another complimentary back. This makes sense for Gibbs. His season at Bama, he got nicked up a bit. I remember how odd it was that Bama wasn’t using Gibbs as a workhorse towards the end of the season the way they’d traditionally done with their lead backs. It made me a little cautious with Gibbs because I wasn’t sure if he could be a workhorse in the NFL. He’s been fantastic so far. This formula is working. That’s what makes it so hard for me to trust him with a high pick. So far I’ve been wrong, and missed out. Next year will be interesting.

Probably. Just like Breece Hall went top 3 in most redraft leagues this year based on how he finished last year….which was also a mistake. And just like with Breece, it won’t be me.

Top 3 if Montgomery is gone. Early 2nd round if Montgomery is there.

I think this is a really good starting point. Nicely done.

Thank goodness!

I’ve been 100% correct every time I’ve disagreed with you. But I do admire how you stick to your guns…

They both look elite, so this seems a little harsh of a reply. I don’t think I’ve ever agreed with TBayXXXVII, but I do here. Must be a NY thing to get defensive over nothing…and where are all the Jets fans that had so much to spew back before the season when a lot of us knew exactly what the Jets were going to be with a washed up, self centered QB that quit on his previous team? Hall at 1 or 2

I thought this thread was about the sandwich. It is a darn good sandwich!

He did not get a happy ending to the season

These are players who “identify” as studs I guess

For example? I’d say they’re basically the same, except Stroud gives OSU the slight edge over Bama at this point.

You are dead on, it’s not these kids fault. Because they are able to display how talented they are at the college level, they are drafted high by really bad teams. To the OPs point, Bryce Young very well could be the best of the class. He’s starting to pick it up. Hopefully for him he’s rewarded by the team with more talent around him this offseason and he actually gets to develop before he gets ruined by a bad organization. How many #1 overall QB draft picks did the Browns ruin before they could develop? Baker Mayfield is a great example of what can happen when one of these guys gets a change of scenery and talent around him before it’s too late. It would be interesting to see what Young could do if he had Tua’s supporting cast.

That they definetly have. It’s a much different skill set, though. RBs have really been hit or miss, probably 50/50…Henry, Gibbs, and Ingram/Harris (to a lesser extent) were hits. You could probably argue that positions which are heavily O-line dependent for success seem to struggle more at the next level. You have to keep in mind that those QBs and RBs were playing behind NFL caliber O-lines at the college level which was a huge advantage and the primary reason for Bama’s success under Saban. They all come back to the pack at the next level. Those glory days are over for Bama now. I guess Saban didn’t want to play anymore now that EVERYONE can pay players w/o consequences. And ESPN will never let a former Saban team suffer the same fate as USC because they still can’t seem to get Saban’s junk out of their mouths!

Young is a product of an Alabama program that clearly doesn’t develop QBs. I don’t know why anyone would’ve thought he’d be any different than every other Alabama QB in the NFL…bad. Tua is the closest thing to a Bama QB that’s almost NFL caliber. Hurts has no idea how lucky he was to be run off by Saban so he could go to Oklahoma to actually be developed as a QB that could play at the next level. So no, Young wasn’t the best QB in that draft.

I could tell them they need to stop Henry to beat the Ravens…think they’d sign me?

If Al Davis, RIP, was still around he’d be a Raider for sure.

In my leagues scoring: Thomas WR6, Nabers WR13, Harrison Jr WR29 And I get to keep Thomas as my 10th rd pick next year…one round higher than drafted the previous year…year after next 9th…and so on.

Waddle likely out, and Hill is questionable (will probably play), plus not a great matchup. I picked up Cooper Rush to play over him.

You’re just mad you didn’t think of it first.

Like it or not, whatever the rules are for the league are what they are…for everyone to exploit. The time to make changes to said rules are before next season starts and complaining about them in season is pointless. I once added and dropped every available QB on a Sunday morning, sending them all to waivers, so the person I was playing couldn’t pick up a QB for his QB that was marked out. D!ck move? Absolutely. Within the rules of the league…absolutely.

Yep, sucks to know you’ve already lost your playoff matchup before the weekend even rolls around!