BetterLateThanNever

I would make that trade. Even in losing Vick, you will have the combo of Flacco/Luck. Luck will be throwing all year as they don't have much of a running game. I also think Austin in better than Maclin. Austin started out injured in training camp and has worked into game shape.

Who would you rather have for the remainder of the year?

I guess it comes down to the point difference between Rodgers and Rivers vs the point difference between Nicks/Young and Calvin Johnson/S Greene. The point diff in Week 1 was Rodgers 25/Rivers 18 for a diff of 7. Nicks 1/Young 0 and Calvin 6/Green 11 for a diff of 16.

In a 10-team redraft league. Play QB/RB/RB/WR/WR/Flex/K/Def. 5pts for throwing TD, 6pts for all others. Been offered P Rivers/Calvin Johnson/Shonne Greene for A Rodgers/H Nicks/T Young. My current team is: QB A Rodgers RB D Murray RB K Smith WR J Jones WR B Marshall Flex H Nicks Bench QB J Flacco RB P Hillis RB J Dwyer RB R Helu WR T Young WR S Rice Would you give up A Rogers in order to have the following lineup? QB J Flacco/P Rivers RB D Murray RB S Greene WR C Johnson WR J Jones Flex B Marshall Thanks for your input!